I dont know if I want to do the garter/bouquet toss at the reception. But I think I DO want FI to take off my garter during a song or something. I know he would make it funny and I also want to surprise him with a Florida Gators garter (he wont know until he takes it off of me).
I know a lot of brides think the whole taking the garter off thing is tacky or whatever, but I will be sure it wont be trashy. And I dont think we'll toss it. I just want him to keep it. He loves FL gators and i thought this would be a cute idea. Now, I also kind of want my cute girly pink garter.
Do the garters have to match? Here is the garter I like for me (just the top one)

Here are the ones I found and cant decide which I like best for FI. They range from like 10-25 bucks.. ( and I would just get the toss garter, the small one)
1.

2.

3.

4.