YAY!
So I finally booked our photographer - we are going with Paul and Cyndy Meyer! First off, a HUGE thank you to everyone for all the advice, and kwynn especially for sending awesome feedback and suggestions.
I have to say there were a few others that I really liked too and it was a hard decision, but I really liked Paul's style most of all. Also, he sent me a packet with info including a DVD with 4 complete weddings on it and an engagement session as well. He also was great with fast responses, and describing things to my non-photography savvy self. And our event manager likes working with him a lot as well, which makes it nice.
*whew* Now on to florists!