Best Bakeries in Pittsburgh for Cookies

LilyWater09

Hi Ladies!

Well my cookie plans completely fell through.  Boo!  So I would appreciate the advice from everyone who has some of the best cookies in the Burgh I can get for my wedding.

Thanks in advance!

eddiesgirl11

Prantls and Potomac bakery would be my pick.Prantls can get expensive though

cgyvhu

I just reviewed cookies after my wedding.  We tried Prantl's, Lincoln, Potomac, Party Cake, Kriebels, Oakmont.... and we liked Potomac and Party cake the best.  Potomac was more affordable and were fantastic to deal with-they delivered them to the venue for us the night before and even made some cookies in our wedding colors.  Everyone loved the cookies at our wedding!

lydiagg

I tasted cookies at a Bridal Show from Prantls & The Priory - both delicious. Also The Vanilla Pastry Studio has amazing treats !

erbear84

I love The Priory, Prantl's, and yes, Vanilla Pastry has great treats!  Haven't tried their cookies but I love them.

Flowerstar1023

Also, I noticed a new bakery in Squirrel Hill called Cakes and Cookies (or something like that - it's on Murray) today. Wonder how they are? And, wonder since they're seemingly new (although I don't go to Squirrel Hill that often) if they'd cut you a deal for good pubilicity?

erbear84

^ Hah, I went to high school with the girl who owns it with her mom.  I haven't tried their cookies yet but they did just open on Saturday, I believe.

TomCat2012

I tried them the day they opened - delicious! Try their ultimate chocolate chip cookie. And I'm a picky Italian when it comes to cookies   We are in talks to use them to boost our cookie table.  also, try The Pie Place and Graham's Bakery in the south hills - the latter is a mom and pop that I grew up with and they make all those cookies from your childhood for cheap.  They couldn't be nicer The Pie Place (they are doing our desserts) has a large cookie and truffle tray for $60  - 7-8 dozen cookies. Not bad if you are in a bind.

jenlynne0624

grandma's country oven bakeshop in harrison city. amazing- my fiance and i got our cake there. they have a ton of choices and do platters and trays and whatnot.