Hi All -
There was a post on here awhile ago saying it was nearly impossible to find grey suits/tuxes to rent. I just wanted to update and give a recommendation. FI and I went to First Class Tuxedo last week and chose the suits they will be wearing. The one we chose is a charcoal grey Joseph Abboud. They also have a lighter grey Calvin Klein suit there as well. We have 5 groomsmen, 2 dads getting suits and a ring bearer. The ring bearer suit is free. FI's suit would be free as well, but we are going to pay for it and divide the discount amongst the groomsmen, so they should be right around $120 for everything including shoes. Anyways, we had a great experience there and it was the first place we went and we were very happy with the selection. They are ordering everything in for FI to try on this week too which is nice that we will see it all put together before we make a final decision. HTH!
Here are some pictures of a JA and CK suit that I think look like the ones they have there (sorry I didn't have style numbers).