My fiance and I are getting married in NJ 10/31/14 and planning on going for our honeymoon either that Saturday Nov 1 or Sunday Nov 2! We finally narrowed it down to these two locations and now I am stuck! I love that St. Lucia has the swim up lagoon rooms for an affordable price but is it worth it being on the first floor? Do you feel like your out in the open? I've never been to either and both locations have similiar lay outs. We are an out going couple who love to meet new people and do activities and def enjoy sipping on cocktails and beers ! Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!