Has anyone been to Jamaica and St. Lucia? Which would you recommend for a honeymoon? We've been dealing with a couple of agents and for some reason they all keep pushing Jamaica even though we tell them we're leaning towards St. Lucia. People that I've spoken to say that Jamaica is beautiful but there are a lot shady characters and places there which is part of why we're leaning towards St. Lucia (not to mention it's beautiful) We're limited with islands to pick from because we want an All Inclusive Hotel and we're going during hurricane season. Jamaica has a lot more AI hotels to choose from whereas in St. Lucia it's really only Sandals.