I am going to wear a custom-made rendition of this Maggie Sottero dress:

I was originally planning to wear these shoes (which I bought almost 2 years ago when I first got engaged):

I love the shoes. They were my first wedding purchase and dictated the whole color scheme. I had originally wanted a super simple gown to go with them, but now that I've fallen in love with this pretty dramatic design, I'm worried it might be too much.
Also, they have gotten pretty dusty because I was a dummy and didn't store them in their box and since they are satin, well, this may be a moot question because it's possible they are ruined. If I have to repurchase, should I get this pair, or something different? I can also get this exact pair in all black. What do you think?