Who has had weddings at these places?
Right now, Worthington Pond Farm is $4000 (on a Friday, 2012) for 12pm to 10pm and includes tables, chairs, dance floors, and use of the gardens, covered bridge, area by the garden for a ceremony and allow outside caterers. I've emailed them back with a few questions (any extra fee for the ceremony) and no response just yet.
Webb Barn is $2,500 for a Friday with $500 per hour afterwards for up to 2 extra hours, which I would do, bringing the cost to $3,500. Includes tables and chairs, allows outside caterers, no extra fee for ceremony.
I LOVE the atmosphere of Webb Barn and is it close to my home (about 20 minutes) versus slightly over an hour for WPFG. I love the barn and the rustic feel. But Worthington Pond Farm is gorgeous too and I like that you get use of their entire grounds for just about the entire day! I think the ceremony by one of their ponds would be nice, at Webb Barn it would be in front of a huge tree with the barn in the background. Both places would allow my dogs to be there too.