Wedding Vows & Ceremony Discussions

Is this the most egocentric idea ever?

My fiance and I are having a traditional Catholic ceremony.  We were both raised catholic, but don't particularly practice.  He is an atheist, I am not.  Having the catholic service was incredibly important to my mother, who may not have recognized our marriage otherwise, and it didn't bother me.  I was raised catholic, i like the ceremony and the solemnity it lends to the whole thing.

The issue is we are also both pretty strong willed/unique people.  I'm going to school for poetry and he's a funny guy.  We had really hoped to write our own vows, but that's not allowed in a catholic ceremony.  We are also not allowed to have a unity candle in my church (some catholic churches you can, i know, but not ours).

So here's the idea we came up with:  When we get to the ceremony, right after we walk in, but before the toasts/food, we were going to do our own little unity candle lighting, and say the vows we'd like to write for each other.  I'm thinking we'll light our own candles, say our vows, and then light the middle one.  This way, we can still experss our love and our committment OUR way, and still have the catholic ceremony as well.

My question is, will our guests totally hate us?  It won't take long, maybe an extra five minutes before dinner is served. . .but will it come across as just completley attention grabby and annoying?  I'd really like a chance to say the vows I'd like to say, and my FH is excited about it, but now I"m worried about pissing off my guests lol.

Thanks :)

Re: Is this the most egocentric idea ever?

  • edited December 2011
    The athiest marrying in a church doesn't make sense to me, but it's your wedding so you should do what you want.
    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • khewesmccoykhewesmccoy member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    Its your day!! Just have the DJ/band (whateverrr) announce that you have written your own vows and would like to take a extra five minutes to say them.

    and PP, I'm an atheist and having a pastor marry me. It's important to my family, and his. I just won't pray when everyone else does, and I don't uphold "getting married in god's eyes" I'm more concerned about the legal aspect of it all.  He's making his FW happy, and there is nothing wrong with that. 
  • edited December 2011
    khewesmccoy, I never said anything was "wrong" with their ceremony. I said it didn't "make sense" to me. I also said she should do what she wants. I'm sure things I'll do at my wedding won't make sense to some people, but it doesn't matter as long as it makes sense to me and my FI. Happy planning all! Laughing
    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • momofaydenmomofayden member
    500 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I would say your personal vows to each other in private in the church afterwards.  It would be totally off to make people sit through a catholic ceremony and then sit through another mini vow recital when you get to the reception. they are going to wonder what in the hell is going on. 
  • khewesmccoykhewesmccoy member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I didnt mean to come off as rude! sorry!!!

    I've come across a LOT of people who were against me doing a wedding in a church!
  • HannahBrombalHannahBrombal member
    10 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I say it's your wedding - do what you want!  The thing I'm learning is that you can't please everybody.  It's your wedding, and you only get one shot at it (hopefully!) and so you better do it the way you want it, otherwise you'll have regrets later.  I don't think people will mind, and I'm sure most people who are at your wedding love you guys and would give you an extra 5 minutes to say your vows to each other.  Even if some people are upset about it, quite frankly, it's not their wedding.  What is most important is that you are happy with your day!
  • edited December 2011
    I like the idea, especially because it's something that YOU and YOUR Fiance WANT to do... it will be cute, quirky, and memorable!!
    I do have to say though, that I am getting married in a Catholic Church as well and we are writing our own vows... our priest just requested that he looks over them so we are actually vowing to the Sacrament of Marriage and not saying something like... "I love your gorgeous Brown eyes as they glisten in the soft moonlight..."

    Maybe you should/could press that idea with your church/priest :)

    GOOD LUCK AND CONGRATS!!!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • jj_5150jj_5150 member
    10 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I would say go for it, I think the idea is cute, if your not doing a long picture slide show thingy I would think it would be ok to do,
    We are planning a big enterance at our reception, that i'm sure will come off as not being part of a normal wedding but what the hell, it's YOUR day have fun and do what you want. If it seems important to the both of you, it will be important for your guesses as well, since they are there to support the two of you on your new life together,
  • edited December 2011
    I agree, this is your FI and your day.  If you guys want to write your own vows, which I think is important then you should make time for it.  Things like this make your wedding unique, like you both are.  Your family/friends will live.  I believe that you and/or your FI will regret not doing someday down the road.
  • edited December 2011
    I say go for it and do it your way.  If it's only 5 minutes, the guests may not mind, and even if they do, this is your day to show your groom how much you love him and vice versa, so to take that part and conform to what other people want is ridiculous.  This is your time.  I'm pretty sure your guests will like it as well.  They have come to see you make your vow so why not?
  • *tinkertoy**tinkertoy* member
    500 Comments
    edited December 2011
    Just playing Devil's Advocate here, if I were a guest at the wedding and the couple did another little ceremony after the Catholic Mass, I'd wonder what the heck was going on.

    I guess you could have someone announce that you want to do special vows, but I'd wonder why you didn't do them in the church, during the one hour wedding ceremony I just sat through.

    It's not like you can explain that you did the church ceremony for the parents and are now doing your own thing.

    ALL THAT SAID...it's your wedding, you can do what you want! Smile
  • YsimerYsimer member
    First Comment
    edited December 2011

    I love your idea!! And it's your wedding day so I think you can do whatever you want to!!! I'm pretty sure, if your guests are people of your family and your friends they'll love to see you telling to the man of your life your compromise with him! I totally agree with you!! =D

    12/18/2010 Can't wait!! =D
  • edited December 2011

    if you want to take 5 minutes out of YOUR day to  say the vows that you all wrote. Then so be it.... its YOUR day... have the DJ or master of ceremony explain what your doing that way your guests wont be confused... i really hope you decide to say the vows you all wrote.. good luck

    FUTURE MRS. ADKINS
  • Snowedin414Snowedin414 member
    10 Comments
    edited December 2011
    From the guest's perspective I think  it would be confusing, I would wonder why I'm seeing this vow exchange after the church service. If you do do it you need to have some sort of explaination, and even then it would strike me as odd. You could also try talking to the priest about inserting something personal somewhere in the church ceremony without replacing the traditional vows.

    Does it need to be public? You could take a little private time anytime during the day and have a meaningful exchange.

  • edited December 2011

    I'm with RetreadBride.

    Roman Catholic ceremonies are symbolic and deeply rooted--to go through the motions is to make a mockery of the ceremony and the faith behind it.

    It is just crazy to make everyone sit through your hour-long-fake-Catholic ceremony (I say fake, because neither of you appear to be having the Catholic ceremony for the right reasons--pleasing your mother is not a "right reason") to endure the one that you feel is real for five minutes.

    It seems that your only opinions on the matter are:
    -I want to please my mother by having a Catholic ceremony.
    and
    -I want to please myself by writing everything.

    Remember to please yourself and your fiance! This is your wedding not hers!

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers BabyFruit Ticker image
  • lisaD26lisaD26 member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    Make that an intro to your first dance?
  • edited December 2011
    I think your idea is great. I am sorry you have to bother with the church thing beforehand as it sounds like that really has nothing to do with you. The later vows sound like you.
  • misslolmisslol member
    500 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I say do it!  Maybe tie it to some other event though - like just before you cut your cake, to open the speeches etc

    Your day, your way!
    December Siggy Challenge
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    Where we met - Mount Isa
    a small mining town in the Australian Outback. Neither of us are from there but we both moved there in the second last year of highschool. He was moved next to me in maths class to stop him talking. It didn't work.
  • edited December 2011
    I'm in the camp with others who say you've already had guests sit through a very long ceremony. If you think your personal vows are important (sounds like you do) then do them privately before leaving the church or during the ceremony when it is one of the many times to pray. You could whisper the "prayer vows" to each other. The priest may allow this with you explaining that you two want to pray together. As a guest I'd rather you spend a few more minutes in the church than making me do a second round of ceremony.
    Regarding the unity candle, I say you do that when you get to the reception site. You don't have to have a big gathering of people around you when you do it. There could be a note near it so people can understand the relevance....this symbolizes our union, etc....
  • ki10ki10 member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I would maybe skip toasts or something if possible, but I don't see how it's egocentric. Atheist myself and kind of offended by atheists marrying through clergy, but whatevs.
  • edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/special-topic-wedding-boards_vows_this-egocentric-idea-ever?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Special Topic Wedding BoardsForum:24Discussion:bd2ba388-66a9-4215-89c2-6cc6c9fe08d5Post:93df0033-f9bd-4719-926e-6e1986d86a45">Re: Is this the most egocentric idea ever?</a>:
    [QUOTE]I part company here. "it's your day, so do what you want" is never a good idea. I think having a ceremony in a faith you don't believe in is both insulting to the faith and a mockery of a solemn ceremony. It's really meaningless to the couple, who is just going through the motions. I understand that it means a lot to some people's families..... but what's going to happen down the road? When one of you dies, or especially when you have children? Will there be a tussle over getting the kids christened, or sending them to parochial school? This is the time to sit down with family members, and point out that "Mom, Dad, I realize this might upset you, but you know I don't share your beliefs."
    Posted by RetreadBride[/QUOTE]

    Both FI and I were raised Catholic, and now we are both agnostic. The whole "to chuch or not to church" issue was a huge deal between me and my mom. My mom is very Catholic, and as hard as it was, and trust me, there was a whole lot of yelling and crying, eventually, I was able to get her to understand that I dont share her beliefs. I explained to her that for me to get married in a church would not only be contrary to our beliefs, but an insult to her faith to "fake it" for her sake. She was concerned that our friend would be marrying us and there was a whole lot of "ohmahgosh what will the family think" but eventually, she saw where I was coming from. She's still not 100% happy with the situation, but she's accepted it and we are still super close. It was rough for a while, but it lead to us having honest conversations about our own personal beliefs that may not have happened otherwies.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards