I did a price comparison at four tuxedo shops. At three of the tux places I did not get a straight answer about the price. Three of the four places said "It depends". One place said that they did all-inclusive pricing so that everybody would know exactly what they would be paying. But I'll start with the ones who didn't give a straight answer first.
Joseph A. Bank said that the price depends on what you get and what upgrades come with it. When asked what an upgrade was, he said things like shoes, a nice shirt and pocket square. They were nearly 200 dollars for a rental. I didn't ask what a not-nice shirt looked like!
Savvi Formalwear gave a similar response and it seemed to be a young person who answered the phone or maybe just a trainee because she didn't seem to know very many answers. When I did get a person who knew the pricing, it was about $180 for everthing.
Men's Wearhouse started with a lowball number, even though I had asked for the price of a nice tuxedo. When I asked again if this was their best they said "no". What's the price with everything for the nicest rental tux that you have? Do you need shoes? "Yes", I said -- everything. It's about $170 plus tax. What an ordeal, just to get a straight answer!
The one straight answer was -- the place where we're getting ours, King Tux Rentals. $149.99 for tuxes that are not black. That includes jacket, pants, shirt, cufflinks vest, tie and pocket square (any color/pattern) and fashionable shoes. Out of curiosity,(I said) how much for black tuxes? "For a 2-button notch lapel, best anywhere tux in black - $119.99 plus tax - all-inclusive"
So the bottom line is
Joseph A Bank $200
Savvi - $180
MW - $170
King Tux - $150 (or $120 if it's a regular black tux)