this is the code for the render ad
Pennsylvania-Philadelphia

Vent - Really long

I've been engaged for about 3 weeks now. The night I got engaged, I texted all of my friends because I was so excited and I wanted to share the news. My best friend basically said congrats, and that was that. When I tried to talk to her over the past few weeks (not about the wedding, I didn't even mention the wedding) she was pretty short with me and she was basically just being really distant. I wasn't sure if it was jealousy because she was the last one in our group to not be engaged, or if it was just plain disinterest, but either way, my feelings were hurt.

I ended up hanging out with her last night and at first it was kind of awkward and I wasn't sure why.. but then in the car, on the way to dinner, she brought up what she's apparently wanted to say to me for weeks but had to wait until she "calmed down and got her feelings under control." She then just went on to say she was "extremely concerned" about our decision to get married, and brought up all these things that make her wonder whether we're ready. She actually said, "You know, after the wedding, you're going to be in a marriage, right?" She was saying we've never lived on our own before except for college, what if he doesn't get a good job after law school, she feels like maybe our parents are validating this and shouldn't be, etc. She said she felt like were skipping some big steps, such as living on our own (which I was never going to do... why would I move out of my parents house where I live for free and move into an apartment where I have to pay rent by myself?) and then living together. Not everyone lives together before marriage and honestly FI's mom would probably throw a fit because she's really religious. So while yes, some people do take those steps, they aren't mandatory steps that everyone should take before getting married.

Some of her concerns were valid, but she didn't say a single thing that FI and I haven't discussed and figured out. The conversation was awkward but after we had it, we were okay and I even asked her to be my MOH. So last night I was fine about everything. When I told FI about it, he got pretty mad and was saying she doesn't know us as a couple that well and that she went about it the wrong way and she should have been supportive and happy for me from the get go, and raised her concerns later, in a different way. He's mad at her for hurting my feelings. Like I said, last night I didn't really have an issue but when I woke up this morning, I started to really agree with him.

I feel like she was wrong to be so distant and totally unwilling to talk to me and it upsets me that she felt SO strongly that she was afraid she'd burst out and say something hurtful before she collected her thoughts. While I appreciate that she cares enough to be concerned, I almost feel like she was raising these concerns as though I'm a child and haven't thought this through. I'm an adult. I understand that life is hard, marriage is hard and things take work. I didn't enter into the decision to get married lightly, nor do I have some unrealistic fantasy about what married life is.

A few months before I got engaged, I told my friends I was starting to freak out and I guess they took it wrong, as though I wasn't sure about my FI and that wasn't the case at all.. it was that I was just starting to panic about the fact that my life was going to change a lot. Change scares me. I try to avoid it. However, some changes are necessary and while yes, I had a small panic episode, it wasn't doubt over my relationship... just a little uncertainty about what exactly the future holds. But nobody can predict exactly what the future holds, so I feel like that's normal.

After she and I had this talk, like I said, things were normal and she said she could get excited for me now and she asked if I knew what I was going to do about MOH (basically whether it would be her or one of my sisters.) So I was like, "Well, since you asked, will you be my maid of honor?" So she said yes and after that she was totally interested in all my plans.

I just can't shake the feeling that she just went about this in the wrong way and I'm upset. I don't want to say anything to her because what would it really do besides make things awkward again? I guess I just needed to vent. I'll get over it, but frankly, I feel like it's a best friend's job to support you in these kinds of things, unless the guy you're engaged to is an abusive alcoholic who beats you or something of that nature. Am I wrong to be a little hurt/upset about this?
imageWedding Countdown Ticker

Re: Vent - Really long

  • There's 2 things I don't understand:

    1. After your friend blindsided you with these thoughts & concerns she's having, and you were obviously upset by the way she felt, why did you ask her to be MOH? Anyone in your bridal party is supposed to stand up for your marriage and support it 100%, and she doesn't sound like she's being all that supportive of it.

    2. After airing her concerns to you, and then you asking her to be MOH, she seemed to do a complete 180 and now she's suddenly interested in your wedding.

    It seems to me that your best friend had some legitimate concerns, but I think she went about telling you the wrong way. I think her heart was in the right place, and she's just looking out for you. She probably knows you better than most people, so I wouldn't take her concerns lightly. I just know that if my best friend had a talk with me like this, I wouldn't have turned around right away and asked her to be MOH.
    Anniversary
  • I think your feelings are valid especially since she expressed that she was going to "burst out and say something hurtful if she hadn't collected her thoughts"...like why was she so dramatic? No one's relationship is perfect and no one is going to live your life but you. I know things were weird and in the heat of the moment she asked about who was going to be your MOH....but I just hope you don't have regrets later about asking her to be your MOH. I also totally agree with you that your BF should support you unless you are in an abusive(physical, mental or emotional) relationship. Give it some time and if you still feel bothered about it talk to her about it and express your feelings because she sure expressed her feelings to you about how she felt.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/local-wedding-boards_pennsylvania-philadelphia_vent-long-1?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Local%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:105Discussion:7c296bae-ecdb-4785-9f06-8770b57216aaPost:d82c6e1d-66d0-4df7-8be8-95e519a94698">Re: Vent - Really long</a>:
    [QUOTE]There's 2 things I don't understand: 1. After your friend blindsided you with these thoughts & concerns she's having, and you were obviously upset by the way she felt, why did you ask her to be MOH? Anyone in your bridal party is supposed to stand up for your marriage and support it 100%, and she doesn't sound like she's being all that supportive of it. 2. After airing her concerns to you, and then you asking her to be MOH, she seemed to do a complete 180 and now she's suddenly interested in your wedding. It seems to me that your best friend had some legitimate concerns, but I think she went about telling you the wrong way. I think her heart was in the right place, and she's just looking out for you. She probably knows you better than most people, so I wouldn't take her concerns lightly. I just know that if my best friend had a talk with me like this, I wouldn't have turned around right away and asked her to be MOH.
    Posted by jessa1228[/QUOTE]

    I guess I felt a little put on the spot when she asked if I'd figured out who my MOH was going to be, so I asked her. I've always wanted her to be my maid of honor and even after the talk, I still want her to be because she's my best friend, but if I had it to do over, I probably would have waited to ask. I guess once we got into the wedding talk, I got excited. I wasn't at all upset about what she said last night... it wasn't until this morning that I started to feel like she went about things the wrong way.

    Her concerns are legitimate, but they were all things that FI and I have already addressed, so I don't feel the need to entertain them further. I'm not really upset that she had concerns...she does know me better than most people, but she honestly doesn't know a lot about the dynamic of my relationship since she only ever sees me with FI when we're in a group.

    What honestly gets me is that when I was with my ex, she was never anything but supportive and then after we broke up and even to this day, she'll come out with these things about how awfully he treated me and how she's glad I'm not with him... yet with FI, who treats me very well, she has reservations that she's not afraid to share. It's just odd how she went about it, I guess.

    You're probably right that I should have waited to ask her to be MOH and if I had it to do over, I would. I  guess I just got caught up in my own excitment.
    imageWedding Countdown Ticker
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/local-wedding-boards_pennsylvania-philadelphia_vent-long-1?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Local%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:105Discussion:7c296bae-ecdb-4785-9f06-8770b57216aaPost:88bbce94-774e-4995-96d8-159460ce1989">Re: Vent - Really long</a>:
    [QUOTE]I think your feelings are valid especially since she expressed that she was going to "burst out and say something hurtful if she hadn't collected her thoughts"...like why was she so dramatic? No one's relationship is perfect and no one is going to live your life but you. I know things were weird and in the heat of the moment she asked about who was going to be your MOH....but I just hope you don't have regrets later about asking her to be your MOH. I also totally agree with you that your BF should support you unless you are in an abusive(physical, mental or emotional) relationship. Give it some time and if you still feel bothered about it talk to her about it and express your feelings because she sure expressed her feelings to you about how she felt.
    Posted by BlissPhilly[/QUOTE]


    That's pretty much my plan, to wait and see how I feel. Hopefully in a few days, I'll be over it. I know she meant well and she just cares about me, but I did feel like she was a little dramatic.
    imageWedding Countdown Ticker
  • I have some thoughts but I'll talk to you about it next time we talk, ok? Not going to put them all out here. 
  • Thanks for listening ladies. I think I'm probably going to let it go. I know she had my best interests at heart and while I wish she had been less distant the last few weeks, I guess I should appreciate that she was worried she'd say something hurtful and didn't want to risk permanently damaging our friendship. I'm still a little bugged right now, but I'll get over it. She is my best friend and I guess sometimes our best friends have to say things we might not want to hear... Again, I just wish she'd handled it a little differently.
    imageWedding Countdown Ticker
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/local-wedding-boards_pennsylvania-philadelphia_vent-long-1?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Local%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:105Discussion:7c296bae-ecdb-4785-9f06-8770b57216aaPost:bcf29ffd-84f5-459f-8149-0547dfbcb3b4">Re: Vent - Really long</a>:
    [QUOTE]Thanks for listening ladies. I think I'm probably going to let it go. I know she had my best interests at heart and while I wish she had been less distant the last few weeks, I guess I should appreciate that she was worried she'd say something hurtful and didn't want to risk permanently damaging our friendship. I'm still a little bugged right now, but I'll get over it. She is my best friend and I guess sometimes our best friends have to say things we might not want to hear... Again, I just wish she'd handled it a little differently.
    Posted by angelstar975[/QUOTE]

    <div>I definitely understand how you feel. Good luck :-/</div>
    Anniversary
  • Wow, sorry about all of this.

    Sounds like she was just concerned about you. I actually think it was nice that she wanted to contemplate how to approach you, rather than just hastily saying something she'll regret. It is still a bit dramatic, but there are always those friends who are a bit alarmist.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Clearly I don't know you or your fiance, but I have had friends who have been blinded by craptastic relationships.  Odds are if your best friend has reservations, thery might be on to something.
    Mrs. JEGs
    est 7.17.10
    [IMG]http://i43.tinypic.com/2md4eb4.jpg[/IMG]
    Hunter Fillmore
    October 1, 2011

    Lizzie In Progress
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/local-wedding-boards_pennsylvania-philadelphia_vent-long-1?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Local%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:105Discussion:7c296bae-ecdb-4785-9f06-8770b57216aaPost:b44726b0-4772-4051-9e9d-2314db608598">Re: Vent - Really long</a>:
    [QUOTE]Clearly I don't know you or your fiance, but I have had friends who have been blinded by craptastic relationships.  Odds are if your best friend has reservations, thery might be on to something.
    Posted by Amerbutt81[/QUOTE]

    Her issues were more that she wasn't sure we were ready for marriage because of never living on our own, etc... not reservations about FI as a person. Having been in a relationship before FI where I was treated pretty poorly, I went into this one with eyes wide open and he really is wonderful. I see the points she was making, but I feel confident that he and I have things figured out. We know we're ready and we're excited to start our life together. I think she understand that now and she's willing to support me.
    imageWedding Countdown Ticker
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards