Okay, so I looked into the "fire island" wedding dream and it turns out although it would be nice, our families want to be there witnessing our marriage. So, there fire island idea would be too much for most people with the walking and ferry. We decided to still keep our dream of getting married on the water.
Instead, we found lombarid's on the bay. Right across from fire is,and, where he proposed, on the bay ( literally) in a beautiful venue!
I'm hoping to spend our honeymoon night at fire island and taking a water taxi there after.
I'm so excited!