this is the code for the render ad
Moms and Maids

Need some advice about future sister-in-law to be......

Hello All, I have never before posted here.  If this topic isn't appropriate to this forum please let me know and I will change it. I wasn't sure where else to post it. Ok, here is the issue, my future sister-in-law really seems to dislike me for some reason and I don't know how to handle their impending engagement and wedding.  I would really appreciate some advice.  I apologize in advance for this taking so long to explain.

Here are the details. I married my husband 12 years ago.  We are very happy together and mostly stay to ourselves when it comes to family issues.  My DH has a brother who is 5 1/2 years younger than him.  They have never been close but we all live in the same town as their parents.  So, we see one another out and about as well as family gatherings.  The girlfriend before the one my b-i-l is currently with had some major emotional/drinking problems that caused all sorts of family drama.  I did not get along with her at all.  Even though my b-i-l broke up with her for having so many issues, he still doesn't like me all that much due to the family drama that occurred all those years ago.

About 5 years ago, b-i-l found his new girlfriend and started bringing her around.  She seemed nice and I tried to get to know her slowly over the last 5 years. About two years ago I figured she didn't have much of an interest in me so I backed way off. Then one night my husband went down to our local firehouse bar to play poker. Since my b-i-l and his girlfriend are EMT/Firefighters they were their playing poker as well.  When it was time for my husband to leave my future s-i-l insisted on walking my DH out to his car and there she proceeded to tell him that she really wanted to be friends with me and then gave DH a banana bread she had specially made for me to take home. She was drunk when she told him all of this but I still thought it was really nice and decided to try to reach out to her again.

So for the next two years I have sent her nice message on FB and invited her over for coffee a few times.  The response I have gotten from her every time I see her is just ....well, I don't know how to describe it but rude.  She acts totally annoyed by me and highly irritated that I bother her on any level. Normally, I would have tried to talk to her about the mixed message I was getting from her but I don't for two reasons:
1) I tried that with the previous girlfriend and that started WWIII, which is why my b-i-l doesn't like me now.
2) My future s-i-l has been fired from two separate jobs because of she is a "bully";. I kid you not, she was really fired from two separate jobs due to her being a bully.  Now, I have never seen her display this kind of behavior but I have seen her act completely overly emotional at the drop of a hat.  Due to this, I will refer you back to point #1.

The last straw for me came two weeks ago.  She started posting some really crazy, over-emotional things regarding her relationship with my b-i-l.  I was literally worried for her.  So, I emailed her basically saying that I didn't want to intrude on her personal life but it was obvious from her posts that she was upset.  And, if she needed a ear to listen or a shoulder to cry on I would happily be there for her.  She totally blew me off.  Ok, I get the message loud and clear.  I am totally backing out of her life and her business.  The issue is that they are getting engaged in the next month ( or so).  At this point, I don't even know if it is appropriate to get her an engagement card and/or gift.  I feel guilty not getting them anything but I also don't really need to feel like a door mat again.  Can someone please give me some advice?  Thanks!

Re: Need some advice about future sister-in-law to be......

  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/special-topic-wedding-boards_moms-maids_need-some-advice-about-future-sister-in-law-to-be?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Special%20Topic%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:357Discussion:b717474d-f224-4ef3-8941-d285884fab4fPost:9c3c8641-bdc5-4441-94c2-ef099d5e9cda">Need some advice about future sister-in-law to be......</a>:
    [QUOTE] <strong>At this point, I don't even know if it is appropriate to get her an engagement card and/or gift.</strong>  I feel guilty not getting them anything but I also don't really need to feel like a door mat again.  Can someone please give me some advice?  Thanks!
    Posted by dollyfinn[/QUOTE]

    I think that to keep the peace you can get something still if they do get engaged. At least in my circle, engagement gifts are small. For example, a card and a picture frame or a bottle of wine. I'm not sure how your H feels about them, but if he is still close with his brother I would still want to support his relationship with his family even if they aren't your favorite people. 

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • ifeelgoodifeelg....Thanks for your advice.  Something small does seem the right thing to do.  My H wouldn't buy his brother a present in a million years but that doesn't mean he wants to rock the boat either.  It will fall to me to figure this out which is why I brought the question to the forum.  Thanks for your advice, it makes a lot of sense.
  • Thank you RetreadBride!
  • A gift is certainly not necessary for an engagement.  I would send them a nice card congratulating them and then leave it alone.

    I think it is kind of silly that your BIL is still mad at you over an ex girlfriend that he hasn't even been with in over 5+ years, but whatever.  Just live your life with your H and stop concerning yourself over whether or not these people like you...you have been trying and trying and sometimes it just isn't worth it and you need to stop.

  • Maggie, thank you for your advice.  It is very much appreciated.  I hear you on the stop trying part.  I have come to the same conclusion myself.  Thanks again!

  • If it is customary to get a gift for an engagement in H's family, then I would get BIL & FSIL a small gift.  Probably something from a Hallmark store that is nice, but inexpensive.  But if gifts are not the norm for H's family, I would just send a card.  These people are/will be your in-laws, so you don't want to rock the boat too much.

    And I would just keep a cordial relationship with FSIL and stop putting in any effort as well.  Sometimes, there is only so much you can do.
  • OliveOilsMom-You said exactly what I have been thinking about mainaining a future relationship peacefully but also doing nothing to actively maintain it either.  Thank you for the feed back and advice, it really helped me to feel that I am thinking straight :)
  • "You've done everything you can to keep the peace, and be a good extended family member. Don't feel guilty, or that you "need to do more."

    Thanks RetreadBride-that has always been my concern.  Family is the most important thing to me and I want to do right by my in-laws.  So, thanks for saying that :)
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/special-topic-wedding-boards_moms-maids_need-some-advice-about-future-sister-in-law-to-be?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Special Topic Wedding BoardsForum:357Discussion:b717474d-f224-4ef3-8941-d285884fab4fPost:0df597c4-07e7-477f-b323-2d523a005fdb">Re: Need some advice about future sister-in-law to be......</a>:
    [QUOTE]A gift is certainly not necessary for an engagement.  I would send them a nice card congratulating them and then leave it alone. I think it is kind of silly that your BIL is still mad at you over an ex girlfriend that he hasn't even been with in over 5+ years, but whatever.  Just live your life with your H and stop concerning yourself over whether or not these people like you...you have been trying and trying and sometimes it just isn't worth it and you need to stop.
    Posted by Maggie0829[/QUOTE]



    Sorry to intrude, but Maggie, I LOVE your bouquet!
  • va4ryan-where we live and in the social circles they run in ,an engagement gift is not customary.  I can tell you that even their best friends will not think to get them an engagement gift.  But, I am the type of person that usually gets other people a gift even if it is not expected.  I see you are from the DC area.  PA is a little different. 

    Also, I do stay out of her life for the most part.  I stay out of it as much as one can when you are all part of the same family, living in the same small town.   I was just trying to be a polite and supportive future sister-in-law. You seem to be implying that I have been overly involved in her life -which I have not.  While I appreciate your desire to be helpful I think you have not understood the situation.  But, again, thank you for your opinion.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards