Wedding Etiquette Forum

Rehearsal dinner - rock and a hard place

FI and I are having a more relaxed, casual feel to our wedding. Our rehearsal dinner is going to be in a private room in our favorite restaurant. FMIL and FSMIL (is that how we abbreviate future-step-mother-in-law?) are splitting the cost evenly, something that they offered to do. FMIL is on a very limited budget while FSMIL has a bit more money to throw around. FMIL isn't really a wedding person. FSMIL loves weddings and all things related to them. Given FMIL's financial constraints, we agreed that we would only invite immediate family and bridal party with SOs to the rehearsal dinner. The total guest list is maybe 30 people all told, so it's a smallish group.

Here's my dilemma. FSMIL has taken over planning the whole thing, which I am fine with to a certain extent since she is paying for half of it. However, at this point, I feel like she's trying to make it into a wedding reception in its own right. We're talking a guest book, favors, etc. for the rehearsal dinner - we're having all that at the wedding the next day! To me it seems very awkward and odd, and makes me a little uncomfortable for some reason. I should also add that I barely know FSMIL, as we've only met once (they turn down every invitation we give them to do something together, come visit, etc.). Her plans also include things like putting awkward baby pictures all over the room (I know this is a tradition for a lot of people at RDs, but I was a very awkward and chubby kid and I am not comfortable having those pictures on display). FMIL wants us to have what we (FI and I) picture - small, casual, relaxed, with no photos, guest book, etc. However, she's not willing to stand up to FSMIL since there is some history there and she's afraid that if she puts her foot down, FSMIL will go running to FFIL, who will call up FI and yell at him (it's happened in the past).

How do we handle this? They are paying equal halves, and FMIL's vision coincides with our vision while FSMIL's does not. Is this a case when it would be appropriate for FI to talk with FSMIL and try to rein in the plans? I know since we aren't paying for the RD ourselves that we're not supposed to have a say unless asked, but it's driving me a little bonkers at this point. I'm afraid I'm going to be sitting there for a couple hours just cringing while people comment on my horrible baby pictures and side-eye each other at the mini-reception feel to the event. Do I smile and bear it or does FI say something?
image

Re: Rehearsal dinner - rock and a hard place

  • I think that it would be appropriate for your FI to talk to his mom, on the vein of that he wants her desires and her budget to be respected.  If he is willing and his mom wants to he can offer to sit down with his mom and step mom to help them talk about what they want. Hopefully she has already given a specific number for the budget. I would stick to the tack that she wants her vision to be respected as well. 

    As far as the pictures thing, does she already have the pictures?  If not, don't give any photos you don't want all over to her and let those that might have access to them that you don't want them shown.  I'd be tempted to compromise and find a couple of childhood photos that you don't mind and give them to her, but otherwise, control what you can control.
  • I agree it's awkward and odd. It's just dinner, yo. It shouldn't be some big shindig mini wedding reception. I would not hesitate to tell her you are uncomfortable with your baby pictures being put out. You should not have to participate in anything that makes you uncomfortable. Other than that, though, I agree you should stay out of it.


    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • Unfortunately, FSMIL contacted my mom and asked for photos before I knew about it, so she already has them. She asked for very specific things (naked bathtub pictures, etc.). Mom now feels badly since she didn't realize I would be so uncomfortable, but she doesn't want to be rude either in saying something to FSMIL.
    image
  • I'd have your FI call up FSMIL and ask for those pictures back. No way in hell would I be showing naked bath time pictures of myself to anyone, not even friends and bridal party. 

    He can also bring up your views of the RD while on the phone with her, but I wouldn't expect much to change. 
  • I'd have your FI call up FSMIL and ask for those pictures back. No way in hell would I be showing naked bath time pictures of myself to anyone, not even friends and bridal party. 

    I know, right? Just the thought of my friends' SOs, the groomsmen, etc. seeing those makes me cringe.

    Thanks for the advice ladies - I'll have FI contact FSMIL and ask that the baby pictures be nixed. Depending on how comfortable he feels with it, maybe he'll comment politely on some of the other things, but we'll probably just let her have her "big shindig mini wedding reception" (to quote Addie) to keep the peace. Really, as long as the baby pictures don't appear I'll probably be okay with it. I think this morning I just needed to explode a bit since I found out about the thumb print tree guest book via e-mail today - I think it's insane to have a guest book for a RD, but I can deal. It's gonna be a pretty sad looking tree, though, with such a small guest list...
    image
  • AddieCakeAddieCake member
    10000 Comments 500 Love Its Fourth Anniversary 25 Answers
    edited May 2013
    I wouldn't hesitate to say something about the pictures. You should not be made to feel uncomfortable. 

    ETA:  Just realized I already said this in my pp. Good grief; I should have slept a little later today. 


    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • What's up with this woman that FMIL AND your mom don't want to go against her? Fi should def approach her about scaling back the event. Or even just getting those baby pictures back.
    image
  • What's up with this woman that FMIL AND your mom don't want to go against her? Fi should def approach her about scaling back the event. Or even just getting those baby pictures back.
    My mom doesn't want to be rude (etiquette is very important to her) and since she already gave the photos she thought it would be rude for her to ask for them back. Given the feedback I've gotten, I say rude be damned, those pictures are not getting displayed at the RD and FI can work on making that happen.

    FMIL usually is a no-nonsense type of lady, but she doesn't want things to backlash on FI if FSMIL gets upset, since it's happened several times in the past.
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards