this is the code for the render ad
Favors

Charity Donation

We are donating to Make A Wish Foundation rather than favors... I think Make A Wish isn't political or religiose so shouldn't bother anyone (who doesn't want to help fulfill wished of children that are battling life threatening illnesses)... Our programs mention that our ceremony is in remembrance of my mom, brother and fiancee's aunt & by the guest book table my idea was to have a picture of each, then a little blurb of we donated to this this charity blurb....  I just have no clue what to say in the blurb... Do I put why this charity is important to us (my brother actually received make a wish) or do I put what the charity does for those that don't know... or do i just put "In lieu of favors we have made a donation to Make A Wish Foundation" and leave it at that? 

Thanks for your help and I have already made the donation I ONLY need advise on what the blurb should say. 
«1

Re: Charity Donation

  • itzMSitzMS member
    2500 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers First Anniversary
    We are donating to Make A Wish Foundation rather than favors... I think Make A Wish isn't political or religiose so shouldn't bother anyone (who doesn't want to help fulfill wished of children that are battling life threatening illnesses)... Our programs mention that our ceremony is in remembrance of my mom, brother and fiancee's aunt & by the guest book table my idea was to have a picture of each, then a little blurb of we donated to this this charity blurb....  I just have no clue what to say in the blurb... Do I put why this charity is important to us (my brother actually received make a wish) or do I put what the charity does for those that don't know... or do i just put "In lieu of favors we have made a donation to Make A Wish Foundation" and leave it at that? 

    Thanks for your help and I have already made the donation I ONLY need advise on what the blurb should say. 

    Well, pin a rose on your nose. Sheesh.

    Out of curiousity, why can't you and your FI just be happy with making the donation in private? Why must you display in a public fashion that you donated to charity? At most,I would put a small frame (5x7) by the guest book with a statement in it that says "Bride and Groom have made a donation to the Make-a-Wish Foundation" If someone wants to ask you about it, they can.

    I would also suggest skipping the pictures on a memory table. Your wedding is supposed to be a happy event, not a memorial service. Seeing the pictures can (and will) make some of your guests sad.

  • if you must advertise that you and your future husband are so fabulous and made a donation to the charity, do the small frame. You don't need a blurb, or any other announcement.  It will come off as AWish and look at me... look at how amazing and generous we are.

    And for the record, just because MakeAWish isn't religious or political, doesn't mean people support it.  A lot of organizations aren't political or religious and they still piss away a lot of their donation money on administrative costs.  People have a lot of different reasons for not supporting charities.  this is why this is generally such a bad idea.

    Why can't you just be happy that you supported the organization?  Why do you have to make it about your wedding?

  • The blurb should say LOOKATME!!!!!!!  Because that's really all you care about if you feel you must make this announcement. If you didn't care if people knew, you wouldn't announce it at all. 
    Don't have favors. Take the money and donate it. Awesome. But there's no need to announce that you did that. 

    People do not say, "In case you're wondering why we have no monogrammed cocktail napkins, it's b/c we donated to charity!" You don't need to explain why something isn't there. 
    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • Don't say anything.

    There is no way to convey a "We donated to charity rather than give you a favor" message to your guests that doesn't come off as AW-ish and "Look what wonderful, generous, people we are not to give you something instead!"

    Also, there are lots of threads on this, but most people aren't keen on weddings used as awareness raisers.  It's not the time for a spiel of any kind about who you think is "in need" or "less fortunate" or any kind of preaching that doesn't come from the officiant.
  • I appreciate the feedback of don't say anything, that is what we will do... In no way is my fiance and I donating to a charity saying that we are "so fabulous" or "LOOKATME" its more we are saying the stupid m&m and mini frames or whatever else are a waste of $ that someone could actually use and I didn't know if guests would be looking for a favor and this would explain why they aren't getting one....but JEEZ ladies you don't have to be rude and assume I am some brat that is selfish is an attention grabber must you assume the most negative things about people?

  • I think you're doing an awesome thing. Why spend money on something people will toss or sit on a shelf, collecting dust. For all these ladies saying it's self centered, I counter with- isn't it is MORE "look at me" to give someone a little plastic something with your names or faces plastered all over it? Seriously? Honestly, I'd rather do something special in honor of our loved ones that are no longer with us, in honor of the good-hearted nature of our family and friends. I say, post a simple message conveying "in lieu of gifts, we have made a donation to XYZ charity, one that has always been near to our hearts and important in the lives of our loved ones. we thank you for being a part in this contribution that will bring happiness to the lives of others, just as they did for <name here>" or something like that. A donation to any charity, supporting any cause that's helping others isn't about YOU, but that doesn't mean you can't bring attention to it and pass along the feeling of joy brought about by supporting others. Not to mention the fact that you have a direct relation to this charity, as do your family and friends. Honoring your lost loved ones through pictures and memories is a beautiful way to keep them alive in your hearts at the wedding. Not only are you helping others by giving a donation in honor of lost ones at your wedding, but your even bringing attention to these special people and happy memories. That's not selfish, that's selfless. And sentimental thoughts will be on your mind as well as your guests as you miss those who cannot be there, so i think it's very sweet of you to remember them and honor them in such a special way. Lucky for you jbouchard, the guests at your wedding will likely be much kinder in heart and much less narrow-minded than the women on these boards. :)

  • NYCMercedesNYCMercedes member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers
    edited June 2013
    jbouchard10132012, I think that is a very nice idea. In my experience, something short and sweet about why the charity would be more than enough. e.g. "In remembrance of my those who were important to us, a donation to Make-A-Wish in their honor. Where there is great love, there are always wishes."

    For the rest of you caddy B*'s - itzMS, FierceFemme, & AddieL73. I think you all miss the purpose of the tribute. Perhaps they are content with everything they have, don't want a new blender, and wanted to honor unfortunate loved ones. If this tribute has somehow brought some self reflection that made you all realize what selfish, absorbed, and lame members of society that you are. Then I will place a donation in all of your names so that you may get a year supply of Symbyax to settle your butts down. 

    (Just in case you don't know what Symbyax is - it is a mood stabilizer to treat bipolar disorder. Go see your doctors and see about getting a wheel barrel full. k? You are welcome.)

    Whoa! Well look at you! TOS out the window. @knotporscha
  • itzMSitzMS member
    2500 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers First Anniversary
    edited June 2013
    auberl88 said:

    I think you're doing an awesome thing. Why spend money on something people will toss or sit on a shelf, collecting dust. For all these ladies saying it's self centered, I counter with- isn't it is MORE "look at me" to give someone a little plastic something with your names or faces plastered all over it? Seriously? Honestly, I'd rather do something special in honor of our loved ones that are no longer with us, in honor of the good-hearted nature of our family and friends. I say, post a simple message conveying "in lieu of gifts, we have made a donation to XYZ charity, one that has always been near to our hearts and important in the lives of our loved ones. we thank you for being a part in this contribution that will bring happiness to the lives of others, just as they did for <name here>" or something like that. A donation to any charity, supporting any cause that's helping others isn't about YOU, but that doesn't mean you can't bring attention to it and pass along the feeling of joy brought about by supporting others. Not to mention the fact that you have a direct relation to this charity, as do your family and friends. Honoring your lost loved ones through pictures and memories is a beautiful way to keep them alive in your hearts at the wedding. Not only are you helping others by giving a donation in honor of lost ones at your wedding, but your even bringing attention to these special people and happy memories. That's not selfish, that's selfless. And sentimental thoughts will be on your mind as well as your guests as you miss those who cannot be there, so i think it's very sweet of you to remember them and honor them in such a special way. Lucky for you jbouchard, the guests at your wedding will likely be much kinder in heart and much less narrow-minded than the women on these boards. :)

    @auberl88

    To the first bolded, not a single regular poster here would ever suggest personalized favors. So your rash generalization is incorrect.

    To the second bolded, what you state is completely contradictory. If you go about telling everyone you've donated to a charity...that does in fact make it about YOU. Look how thoughtful and generous WE are. If you choose to donate to charity, that is awesome, but it should be kept private.

    To the third bolded...again, you contradict yourself. Happy memories and missing someone who can't be there do not go hand in hand. Having pictures of the deceased can an will stir up sadness in a lot of guests.

  • itzMSitzMS member
    2500 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers First Anniversary
    Oh no ... I'm going to concern myself with my Knot account. It is not like I live to ridicule strangers on a random post rather than help. I'm more concerned with people looking to be all nasty and uppity rather than help. Is it really that hard to be a decent human being? 

    COMMON DECENCY out the window!
    Who was ridiculing?
  • itzMS, you're right no one mentioned personalized favors but that's the norm nowadays. So I appoligize for anyone offended by my "rash" generalization.

    But here's where I have a problem... it is the bride's Mother and Brother, and groom's aunt that they are remembering... not some second cousin no one can remember or an older "life-well-lived" grandparent... Whatever she and her fiance decide are respectful and hertfelt ways to honor those people are their choices. I will not get into a philosophical discussion about altruism. I will not remind anyone about loss and grief of loved ones, how everyone handles these situations differantly. But I will say I stand by my statements of the couple honoring their lost loved ones in whatever ways they feel those people would deserve and be proud of them for.

    The only question she asked was about what to say and how to say it, and that should be the only replies given to this post...


  • Good god, itzMS! You are the bolding queen! OK, I'm going to help you out here, ready?

    rid·i·cule    /ˈridiˌkyo͞ol/
    Noun
    The subjection of someone or something to mockery and derision.

    Your first line above - 'Well, pin a rose on your nose. Sheesh.'
    THAT is ridicule. The rest of your statements is just blatant classlessness with ridicule. 

    Plus your 'break down' of auberl88's posting is just a clear indication of someone who is desperate to not only prove herself right. As someone who has lost someone close - YES, you can have happy memories of someone you miss. Case in point, I miss a lost parent, I miss him, and when I remember him there are plenty of happy memories that come with remembering him. 

    Listen, I could break down your unintelligible posts with bold marks and such. But I can honestly feel the nastiness radiating from you, over the internet, to me. When looking over posts on this site where people request help on something I will provide just that - help. Not nasty remarks because perhaps my marriage is so fruitless that I need to take out my loveless anger out on people requesting their productive opinion. 

    See what I mean? You are poisonous. 
    So.....you don't think she was nice, and that's not ok in your book, but you get to insult her marriage, and that IS ok? Hmmmm. 


    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • Good god, itzMS! You are the bolding queen! OK, I'm going to help you out here, ready?

    rid·i·cule    /ˈridiˌkyo͞ol/
    Noun
    The subjection of someone or something to mockery and derision.

    Your first line above - 'Well, pin a rose on your nose. Sheesh.'
    THAT is ridicule. The rest of your statements is just blatant classlessness with ridicule. 

    Plus your 'break down' of auberl88's posting is just a clear indication of someone who is desperate to not only prove herself right. As someone who has lost someone close - YES, you can have happy memories of someone you miss. Case in point, I miss a lost parent, I miss him, and when I remember him there are plenty of happy memories that come with remembering him. 

    Listen, I could break down your unintelligible posts with bold marks and such. But I can honestly feel the nastiness radiating from you, over the internet, to me. When looking over posts on this site where people request help on something I will provide just that - help. Not nasty remarks because perhaps my marriage is so fruitless that I need to take out my loveless anger out on people requesting their productive opinion. 

    See what I mean? You are poisonous. 
    Well isn't this post pleasant. No one has said any nasty remarks. They're being blunt and giving their opinion, which is the whole point of a forum.

    OP, I'd leave indications of giving to charity out for reasons PPs said. If you feel that you must include a little blurb about it, I'd put it either in the program or with the guest book. Something short and sweet will suffice, "In lieu of favors, Bride and Groom have donated to the Make-a-Wish Foundation in remembrance of loved ones."
  • auberl88 said:


    The only question she asked was about what to say and how to say it, and that should be the only replies given to this post...

    That line is growing so tiresome. What is it that people can't grasp here?  When you post on a message board, you don't get to decide or control what people say. If they have thoughts and opinions about it, they are going to supply them. 

    To quote @FierceFemme "If you asked us what kind of getaway car to use in your bank heist, we're going to tell you that's a bad idea, even though ALL you asked was what kind of car you should drive." 


    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • AddieCakeAddieCake member
    10000 Comments 500 Love Its Fourth Anniversary 25 Answers
    edited June 2013
    jbouchard10132012, I think that is a very nice idea. In my experience, something short and sweet about why the charity would be more than enough. e.g. "In remembrance of my those who were important to us, a donation to Make-A-Wish in their honor. Where there is great love, there are always wishes."

    For the rest of you caddy B*'s - itzMS, FierceFemme, & AddieL73. I think you all miss the purpose of the tribute. Perhaps they are content with everything they have, don't want a new blender, and wanted to honor unfortunate loved ones. If this tribute has somehow brought some self reflection that made you all realize what selfish, absorbed, and lame members of society that you are. Then I will place a donation in all of your names so that you may get a year supply of Symbyax to settle your butts down. 

    (Just in case you don't know what Symbyax is - it is a mood stabilizer to treat bipolar disorder. Go see your doctors and see about getting a wheel barrel full. k? You are welcome.)
    The word is catty, not caddy. And since my mother was bi-polar, I find it particularly offensive that you throw that around so casually and as an insult to someone. 


    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • OP - I suggest not saying anything -or- making a small note in the program saying that a donation has been made to the charity.

    Don't use "in lieu of favors". 


    image   imageimage
    You'll never be subject to a cash bar, gap, potluck wedding, or b-list if you marry a Muppet Overlord.

  • edited June 2013
    MuppetFan said:
    OP - I suggest not saying anything -or- making a small note in the program saying that a donation has been made to the charity.

    Don't use "in lieu of favors". 


    I didn't think of that- that is a great suggestions since they are in the programs already. Thanks! "In remembrance of Name, Name Name a donation has been made to Make a Wish
  • Yes. Make it discreet. When you announce things to people in such a way to make a statement so that they knew you made the donation...it just doesn't translate well to guests (as you can see from the comments from PPs).

    At a wedding I went to, there was something similar to this written in the honor of the bride's mother to a music for children foundation:

    With loving thoughts and fond memories today of Janice Beck and her love of children, a donation to Make a Wish was made in her honor.

    It was discreet in the program. She also used music notes as accents in honor of her mother.  Her bouquet had some sheet music ribbon tied around it...that kind of thing.
    image   imageimage
    You'll never be subject to a cash bar, gap, potluck wedding, or b-list if you marry a Muppet Overlord.

  • MuppetFanMuppetFan member
    500 Love Its 1000 Comments First Answer Name Dropper
    edited June 2013
    dup post
    image   imageimage
    You'll never be subject to a cash bar, gap, potluck wedding, or b-list if you marry a Muppet Overlord.

  • @itzMS thanks for paging me, ladies. She is banned.
  • Thanks, KP!  You're rocking this week!
    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • jbouchard10132012, I think that is a very nice idea. In my experience, something short and sweet about why the charity would be more than enough. e.g. "In remembrance of my those who were important to us, a donation to Make-A-Wish in their honor. Where there is great love, there are always wishes."

    For the rest of you caddy B*'s - itzMS, FierceFemme, & AddieL73. I think you all miss the purpose of the tribute. Perhaps they are content with everything they have, don't want a new blender, and wanted to honor unfortunate loved ones. If this tribute has somehow brought some self reflection that made you all realize what selfish, absorbed, and lame members of society that you are. Then I will place a donation in all of your names so that you may get a year supply of Symbyax to settle your butts down. 

    (Just in case you don't know what Symbyax is - it is a mood stabilizer to treat bipolar disorder. Go see your doctors and see about getting a wheel barrel full. k? You are welcome.)

    Whoa! Well look at you! TOS out the window. @knotporscha

    I know this asshat got banned, but just in case anyone else is taking this serious.  I make lots and lots and lots of donations to causes I find valuable.   I just didn't feel the need to advertise them at my wedding.

    No one here EVER says "oh, DON'T make a donation to a charity you love and support".  They are saying.  Sure, give as much money as you wannna.  Shit, elope and give your entire wedding budget to your charity. We don't care. But, don't make some big announcement about it. 

    None of have any vested interest in what anyone else does for their wedding. what we are doing you is giving you blunt, honest opinions.  And you can be certain that at least some of your guests will feel the same way, but they won't have the heart to tell you.

    And, @auberl88 --  plastic trinkets, shot glasses, mugs, with your name & date on them suck. No one here recommends those.  It's one thing to give someone a lil edible in a bag or box with a label on it, it's another thing to expect someone to drink out of a cup with your name & date on it for the next decade .

  • Thank you, FF!  I second that. People always accuse us of saying NOT to donate, but that's not the point of our responses. AT ALL.

     It's like people get blinders on and don't want to be told their plan isn't good, so they don't bother to actually read and comprehend our responses. 





    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • auberl88 said:

    I think you're doing an awesome thing. Why spend money on something people will toss or sit on a shelf, collecting dust. For all these ladies saying it's self centered, I counter with- isn't it is MORE "look at me" to give someone a little plastic something with your names or faces plastered all over it? Seriously? Honestly, I'd rather do something special in honor of our loved ones that are no longer with us, in honor of the good-hearted nature of our family and friends. I say, post a simple message conveying "in lieu of gifts, we have made a donation to XYZ charity, one that has always been near to our hearts and important in the lives of our loved ones. we thank you for being a part in this contribution that will bring happiness to the lives of others, just as they did for <name here>" or something like that. A donation to any charity, supporting any cause that's helping others isn't about YOU, but that doesn't mean you can't bring attention to it and pass along the feeling of joy brought about by supporting others. Not to mention the fact that you have a direct relation to this charity, as do your family and friends. Honoring your lost loved ones through pictures and memories is a beautiful way to keep them alive in your hearts at the wedding. Not only are you helping others by giving a donation in honor of lost ones at your wedding, but your even bringing attention to these special people and happy memories. That's not selfish, that's selfless. And sentimental thoughts will be on your mind as well as your guests as you miss those who cannot be there, so i think it's very sweet of you to remember them and honor them in such a special way. Lucky for you jbouchard, the guests at your wedding will likely be much kinder in heart and much less narrow-minded than the women on these boards. :)

    Someone is angry. 
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • jbouchard10132012, I think that is a very nice idea. In my experience, something short and sweet about why the charity would be more than enough. e.g. "In remembrance of my those who were important to us, a donation to Make-A-Wish in their honor. Where there is great love, there are always wishes."

    For the rest of you caddy B*'s - itzMS, FierceFemme, & AddieL73. I think you all miss the purpose of the tribute. Perhaps they are content with everything they have, don't want a new blender, and wanted to honor unfortunate loved ones. If this tribute has somehow brought some self reflection that made you all realize what selfish, absorbed, and lame members of society that you are. Then I will place a donation in all of your names so that you may get a year supply of Symbyax to settle your butts down. 

    (Just in case you don't know what Symbyax is - it is a mood stabilizer to treat bipolar disorder. Go see your doctors and see about getting a wheel barrel full. k? You are welcome.)

    Whoa! Well look at you! TOS out the window. @knotporscha

    I know this asshat got banned, but just in case anyone else is taking this serious.  I make lots and lots and lots of donations to causes I find valuable.   I just didn't feel the need to advertise them at my wedding.

    No one here EVER says "oh, DON'T make a donation to a charity you love and support".  They are saying.  Sure, give as much money as you wannna.  Shit, elope and give your entire wedding budget to your charity. We don't care. But, don't make some big announcement about it. 

    None of have any vested interest in what anyone else does for their wedding. what we are doing you is giving you blunt, honest opinions.  And you can be certain that at least some of your guests will feel the same way, but they won't have the heart to tell you.

    And, @auberl88 --  plastic trinkets, shot glasses, mugs, with your name & date on them suck. No one here recommends those.  It's one thing to give someone a lil edible in a bag or box with a label on it, it's another thing to expect someone to drink out of a cup with your name & date on it for the next decade .

    I highlighted what I am responding to- I didn't think a tiny frame with "donations are being made to Make-A-Wish foundation"  was a big announcement. 
    And honestly this bored has taught me no to ask others people's opinions on things and just do what I think is right because I will never make everyone happy. If I don't recognize those that passed on  then I for sure know that my immediately family would be hurt and I would as well.

  • I know this asshat got banned, but just in case anyone else is taking this serious.  I make lots and lots and lots of donations to causes I find valuable.   I just didn't feel the need to advertise them at my wedding.

    No one here EVER says "oh, DON'T make a donation to a charity you love and support".  They are saying.  Sure, give as much money as you wannna.  Shit, elope and give your entire wedding budget to your charity. We don't care. But, don't make some big announcement about it. 

    None of have any vested interest in what anyone else does for their wedding. what we are doing you is giving you blunt, honest opinions.  And you can be certain that at least some of your guests will feel the same way, but they won't have the heart to tell you.

    And, @auberl88 --  plastic trinkets, shot glasses, mugs, with your name & date on them suck. No one here recommends those.  It's one thing to give someone a lil edible in a bag or box with a label on it, it's another thing to expect someone to drink out of a cup with your name & date on it for the next decade .

    I highlighted what I am responding to- I didn't think a tiny frame with "donations are being made to Make-A-Wish foundation"  was a big announcement. 
    And honestly this bored has taught me no to ask others people's opinions on things and just do what I think is right because I will never make everyone happy. If I don't recognize those that passed on  then I for sure know that my immediately family would be hurt and I would as well.
    Small or large, any kind of announcement is not necessary. Why do you need to announce it?  Why can't you just do it silently?


    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • Please check out any charity before you make a donation to it.  There are a number of "watchdog" sites out there that do this.  CNN had a report last week on "the top ten worst charities in America."  I didn't know about Make A Wish myself until a couple of years ago, when I read one of these reports. 

    Don't donate to the American Lung Association, the American Heart Association or the American Cancer Society without SPECIFYING what you want your donation to be used for.  They will use your donation for disease research......IF you specify that this is where you want it to go.  Otherwise they'll decide, and a high percentage of their costs are administrative.  The heads of these orgs have outrageous salary packages. So does the head of the Red Cross, although that is somewhat justifiable, since the Red Cross is worldwide, and has so much to do.

    A bit off topic, but I thought it was important.
    You don't get a highly qualified CEO of a national organization without paying them accordingly.  The American Red Cross CEO, Gail McGovern, makes $500,000 a year, which is a competitive wage for a CEO of a major national organization but not outrageous.  McGovern has made a HUGE difference in terms of the organization's financial stability, which is exactly why she was hired in 2008.  In 2008 the ARC was running at a $209 million budget deficit; it was spending $209 million more each year than it took in in donations.  Because of her actions and the changes she instituted by 2010 the deficit was down to $33 million.  That's huge.  Her salary is only .01% of expenses.  According to Charity Navigator only 4% of the charity's expenses goes to administrative expenses.  92.2% goes directly to program expenses, which means that 92 cents out of every dollar goes directly to helping people.  ARC has a score of 70 out of 70 for accountability and transparency and 55.35 out of 70 for financial, and an overall score of 59.64 out of 70.

    Also, ARC is the designated affiliation in the US of the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, which consists of 188 different Societies (i.e., it's financial and organizationally separate).

    If you want your donation to go to your local chapter you can indicate so on your check and it will be honored.  You can also designate to other specific causes, such as the relief effort in Moore, OK, or Sandy (which is still ongoing), or whatever.



  • Also, Retread, MAW's score on Charity Navigator isn't too bad.  They have a total score of 58.36 out of 70.  Program expenses are 72.7% of their budget, administrative expenses are 9.8%, and fundraising expenses are 17.4% (this is the number I think is a bit high, but I don't know how it breaks down).  CEO makes $441,000 a year.



  • Back to the topic at hand, I'm on team Not a Favor and team Don't Advertize Your Donations.



  • I hear you on that, Retread.  I've volunteered with the ARC since I was 13, and I'm heavily involved in disaster relief both nationally and in my community.



This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards