Wedding Woes

My dad deserves his 'death sentence'

Dear Prudence,
My father is 77 years old. After over 50 years of enthusiastic smoking, he has finally been diagnosed with Stage IV lung cancer. I’m 37 years old and since I can remember I have worried that this day would come. He loves to talk about himself, so he calls me and goes on and on with the latest updates, and how he is sure the next round of treatments will cure him. (The five-year survival rate for people with his diagnosis is 1 percent.) Beginning when I was a small child, I tried to get him to quit by using persuasion, anger, heartfelt letters, throwing out his cigarettes, even family therapy a few years ago, all to no avail. He would often get angry and defensive and even called me "selfish" for describing how his smoking affected me. I'm fed up and having a hard time mustering sympathy for his self-inflicted disease. And he is still smoking! Part of me feels that I should be a loving and supportive daughter to my ill father. But my feelings are so clouded by anger that he has chosen cigarettes over his health and more years with his family that I don't feel like responding with concern and good wishes. Is there anything to do but swallow my feelings and feign polite concern?

—Slow Suicide Is Still Suicide

Re: My dad deserves his 'death sentence'

  • As a child of a smoker, I cannot say I don't understand how this person feels.
  • Look, dude smoked. He made it to 77 anyway, which is pretty damn good. She could have enjoyed all those years with him and made him smoke on the porch or whatever. 

    But this chick's been trying to change someone else's behavior *her whole life*? She must be a joy to be around. 
    image
  • Yes, because a smarmy-ass "I told you so, MFer" mentality cures stage IV cancer.
    imageAlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • She has a right to her feelings.

    But they also irritate me.  You know what other activity we're all engaged in that has a death sentence?  Life.  He's 77, that's not that far short of life expectancy for a man in the US.  He could die of any number of other things and she wouldn't "feel" like this.  I don't care if he's a smoker, no one "deserves" lung cancer.  This isn't comeuppance or divine revenge for smoking. She's being rather sanctimonious.

  • I've been there with my stepfather (passed away in 1999)and while it was extremely difficult he was an adult and while I hate smoking he made his own decisions. Everyone, parents included do things that we don't agree with or that can cause us/them harm but who are we to tell them how to live their lives. All you can do it be there and support him or back away and miss out on what could potentially be the last months/years with him. I think you would regret not being there for him. I would definitely put my feelings aside.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • My mom died from complications from smoking related cancer. After ten years of watching her slowly starve to death because she couldn't eat, having the doctor carve pieces off her in the hopes that 'this time it will work', and having her beg me to kill her, the idea of anyone saying someone 'deserves' to die is reprehensible to me. Sure he may have made the wrong choices, but no one 'deserves' to have to suffer like that.
  • No one deserves to die this way-lung cancer is a horrible, horrible death, and you will know that soon enough.

     

  • Although I can relate to your feelings of frustration and anger (my dad died of lung cancer caused by smoking his whole life when I was only 16), you will regret these emotions if they put a rift between you and your father during his last months/years of life. Don't "swallow your feelings and feign polite concern", actually get over it or you will regret it for the rest of your life.

  • jlhart76 said:
    My mom died from complications from smoking related cancer. After ten years of watching her slowly starve to death because she couldn't eat, having the doctor carve pieces off her in the hopes that 'this time it will work', and having her beg me to kill her, the idea of anyone saying someone 'deserves' to die is reprehensible to me. Sure he may have made the wrong choices, but no one 'deserves' to have to suffer like that.
    I think people who think a garment bag is a carry-on deserve this level of suffering in their endtimes.
    image
  • 3 years ago my father was diagnosed with Stage 3 rectal cancer.   I spent a lot of time being angry at him because he refused to get a colonoscopy and his best friend died of the disease(a colonoscopy can help prevent the disease).  He's a stubborn idiot who did this to himself.   But in the end, he's still my dad and I still love him. 

    Maybe your dad is constantly talking about the treatments to keep his spirits up and to deal with his guilt. 

    At this point, considering that you've deemed him to have a death sentence, just let go of your anger and spend the time with him while you can.   If you don't, you will regret it.   Don't let him die with you angry at him.

  • @Auntflo, Christmas has come about 5 times in this post.  ;)
  • @Auntflo, Christmas has come about 5 times in this post.  ;)
    I was just about to post this. 
    image
  • God bless us every one.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards