Our wedding is video game themed so we thought Mario Star Tins filled with star shaped mints and Mario '?' Boxes filled with sour candy would be appropriate. Originally we wanted Moogle Head Cookies from an online business I found last year that did very good work. But they have since stopped taking orders, not really sure why.
At first we were upset and I was freaking out because those cookies were so cute and would have been perfect. Oh well, no use crying over spilled milk or lost cookies.