Wedding Woes

Am I wrong about being upset?

A few months back, I showed pictures of my gown to FMIL.  I told her the color of the dress was a cream/off white color.  She said it was beautiful and asked me what colors she was allowed to wear so she could figure out a dress for the day of.  I told her no white/cream/ivory/off white color.  She said ok.  We didn't talk anything more about it.  My FSMIL asked me what color she could wear and I told her the same thing.  She said to me that she would never steal the spot light from me like that as she knows better.  She plans to wear a plum/wine color.  Which I think is beautiful.  Mind you, this was months ago (lets say around October).  I even emailed all Mothers (FSMIL, FMIL, and My mom) and reminded them that I didn't want them wearing those colors...anything else was fine but not anything close to my dress.  FMIL replied that she understood and said she was thinking about possibly wearing a grey/greyish blue color.  

Fast forward to Saturday.  I asked FI if he knew whether or not his mom had gotten her dress for the wedding yet.  He said he wasn't sure and would call.  He called and she said that she was thinking about wearing the dress from his sisters wedding 6 years ago.  When we visited FFIL & FSMIL that evening, I looked at the photo album and saw the dress his mom was going to wear.  It's OFF WHITE/CREAM!!!!!!  I looked at it again and told FI that I didn't appreciate the fact that I told her NO to that color and she is trying to wear something IN that color.  He said he would talk to her.  Which he did.  FI told me that she doesn't have the extra $200.00 to go spend on a gown for his wedding. He offered that we would take her out, one weekend soon, to pick out a dress for her to wear.  When I got home I talked with FI.  I told him that there are numerous places that she can get a beautiful dress for not too much money.  I found NUMEROUS dresses that are BEAUTIFUL for under $100 at Burlington Coat Factory, Boscovs, Macys, Dress Barn (yes, Dress Barn has some BEAUTIFUL dresses).  I took screenshots of some and sent them to him to look at.  There are a few that he really liked from BCF that are well under $100 and would be perfect for her.  

What I don't understand is how the one thing that I was extremely specific about, is not being followed by FMIL.  It is common knowledge that you don't wear any color close to the brides dress...hell, you don't wear white PERIOD. Am I wrong for being upset about this?  I haven't cried much during this wedding planning process.  I have only cried a few times as there have been things that have made me emotional (my dress, some gifts from my shower that were handed down from my Mom's Mom).  I have been in tears every time I think about this.  I was told by a few people that I should be upset and rightfully so.  Any advice/tips?  
Wedding Countdown Ticker
Michelle & Ronald
01/03/81
06/18/81
08/25/10
05/07/13
03/15/14

image172 Invites sent
image 132 adults and 3 kids are party animals
image 40 are party poopers
image 0 awaiting reply
Need 8 adults to make minimum.  Eek.
«1

Re: Am I wrong about being upset?

  • edited January 2014
    scribe95 said:
    I think this is not something to be crying about. You are the bride. No one will get confused.

    She apparently has a dress that she loves and doesn't have the money for a new one. And frankly, while it's nice of you guys to offer to buy her a dress, some people aren't comfortable with charity like that. Let it go.
    Sadly, this is not something I will let go.  She has been made well aware that she isn't supposed to wear this color and she "forgot."  BS! She has been told and reminded a few times.  FI has even told her numerous times too.  She is just doing this because she wants the attention....which she has successfully taken from me numerous times before in the past when it came to wedding appointments, etc.  I would go into the full list but lets just say there are times when I have gotten comments asking me who the bride is.  
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    Michelle & Ronald
    01/03/81
    06/18/81
    08/25/10
    05/07/13
    03/15/14

    image172 Invites sent
    image 132 adults and 3 kids are party animals
    image 40 are party poopers
    image 0 awaiting reply
    Need 8 adults to make minimum.  Eek.
  • mrsconn23mrsconn23 member
    Knottie Warrior 10000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited January 2014
    scribe95 said:
    I think this is not something to be crying about. You are the bride. No one will get confused.

    She apparently has a dress that she loves and doesn't have the money for a new one. And frankly, while it's nice of you guys to offer to buy her a dress, some people aren't comfortable with charity like that. Let it go.
    Sadly, this is not something I will let go.  She has been made well aware that she isn't supposed to wear this color and she "forgot."  BS! She has been told and reminded a few times.  FI has even told her numerous times too.  She is just doing this because she wants the attention....which she has successfully taken from me numerous times before in the past when it came to wedding appointments, etc.  I would go into the full list but lets just say there are times when I have gotten comments asking me who the bride is.  
    So, you're going to continue to let her get to you and make you miserable.  Mmmkay. 

    There is a solution to her 'taking attention' from you at your wedding related stuff: Stop inviting her along.  

    Seriously, you will be the one standing up at the front of the crowd and getting married to your FI.  No one will mistake her for you or whatever. 

    Also, forcing your FI to go out and dress a grown woman is just weird. 

    Letting this shit not get to you is good practice for the future.  Because if she's really this over-bearing and/or attention seeking, it's not going to change once there's no longer a wedding to plan. 
  • If you have all of these rules that must be followed, then I think it's only right for you to buy her dress.
    image
  • HeffalumpHeffalump member
    Knottie Warrior 5000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited January 2014
    I disagree, NOLA. I think her MIL should be able to wear whatever she wants. It's not the bride's place to issue rules about how her MIL--presumably, a mentally competent adult--can dress herself, whether she offers to pay or not. FMIL is not interested in having them buy her a dress, so OP needs to drop it.

    OP sounds like she's just being controlling for the sake of being controlling. That never ends well.
  • Heffalump said:
    I disagree, NOLA. I think her MIL should be able to wear whatever she wants. It's not the bride's place to issue rules about how her MIL--presumably, a mentally competent adult--can dress herself. OP sounds like she's just being controlling for the sake of being controlling. That never ends well.
    If she's gonna INSIST on being 'that guy', then she should buy the dress. If she decides to grow up and not be 'that guy', then she'll realize she's being stupid and let her FMIL dress herself. But she's made it obvious that she's gonna be 'that guy', sigh.

  • I have to agree with Juicy. Yes, I give everyone on here a nickname.

    The lady should wear what she wants to wear, but ol' girl said she isn't going to let this one go.

    image
  • I have to agree with Juicy. Yes, I give everyone on here a nickname.

    The lady should wear what she wants to wear, but ol' girl said she isn't going to let this one go.

    Well, unfortunately I have to agree with you about her letting it go. I don't get it, at ALL, but there it is.
  • My wedding must be invalid then because my mom write off white as well.

    Trust that no one thought she was the one getting married and my mom looked fantastic.
  • What I"m taking for this:  I want to know all of our nicknames from NOLA.

    And yes, you're wrong for being upset.  Your answer should've been, "Whatever you want to wear, FMIL, it doesn't matter to me".  I would change it to that now, so that you don't look like a whiny baby.

    Also, for some reason I hear "tzuj" (I think that's the official spelling, it the Queer Eye for the Straight Guy saying) when I think of @thejucheidea.
  • Juicy is actually a pretty common nickname for me because I always use Juche online and very few people know how Juche is actually pronounced, lol. There are more now that Kim Jong-un is becoming more maniacal than his father, but still not many.

  • How is it correctly pronounced, @thejucheidea? I've always been curious. I've seen the word written many times but never heard it said.

    OP, you asked if you're wrong to be upset. The answer is yes. It sounds like your FMIL likes getting a rise out of you, and does things to push your buttons and you give her the satisfaction of reacting.

    Stop reacting.
    Anniversary

    image
    I'm gonna go with 'not my circus, not my monkeys.'
  • I told both my mom and my FSMIL to wear whatever they were comfortable/felt pretty in, but that I wanted to be the only one in white. Both said "well, duh, of course!"

    Mom did ask my thoughts before she went shopping. I told her (and repeated it when telling FSMIL about Mom's dress shopping saga) that she was welcome to wear champagne/gold like the flower girls if she wanted to, but that I thought personally that dark green or blue would be very complimentary colors. Mom got something in sea foam (I haven't seen it yet), and said she tried on champagne dresses, but she felt they made her look pasty/washed out.

    To clarify on matching the FGs: at my bro's wedding last May, we were told they were just going to have flower girls. Fine. Once we arrived, we found out that while MOB and MOG were wearing lighter shades of the purple that was one of the wedding colors, my sister (Bro and sis are half sibs to me, full to each other) was wearing a dark purple dress exactly matching the wedding color, and SIL's sister was wearing an orange/red dress matching the other wedding color. SIL's brother had on a purple tie to match. I had deliberately not gotten a beautiful purple dress in favor of a light blue one so that I wouldn't look like I was intruding on the wedding party- I was the only sibling who didn't have a wedding color on, and I felt like an outsider. That's why I told my Mom and FSMIL if they wanted to match with the colors we picked, to go for it.

  • Ha. Usually just a shorten version of your screen name.
    image
  • You don't get to tell any of your guests how to dress. It is rude and very controlling. FMIL clearly likes her off white dress and she is having money issue. Stop making an issue out of this. You dont want to hurt your relationship with your FMIL.
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • It's kinda... dzju-chuh. The 'j' is like the French 'j'.

  • "dzju"? no. it's more like "joo cheh." there is no glottal stop, or that is some weird accent going on there.

    anywho @soontobemrsbuccheri -- be mad all you want. but unless she wants to wear a veil, stop caring.

    hey, have you ever heard the story of the epic 34th wedding anniversary party? 


    image
  • scribe95 said:
    I think this is not something to be crying about. You are the bride. No one will get confused.

    She apparently has a dress that she loves and doesn't have the money for a new one. And frankly, while it's nice of you guys to offer to buy her a dress, some people aren't comfortable with charity like that. Let it go.
    Sadly, this is not something I will let go.  She has been made well aware that she isn't supposed to wear this color and she "forgot."  BS! She has been told and reminded a few times.  FI has even told her numerous times too.  She is just doing this because she wants the attention....which she has successfully taken from me numerous times before in the past when it came to wedding appointments, etc.  I would go into the full list but lets just say there are times when I have gotten comments asking me who the bride is.  
    She isn't supposed to, isn't allowed?  Sheesh, it's a freaking dress get over it IMO.

    I don't understand brides who think a guest in white is somehow going to confuse everyone else into thinking that she is actually the bride.  You never hear the poor grooms lamenting about guests wearing black tuxes and suits too!

    You really think what someone else is wearing is going to take the attention and focus off of you?  And honestly so what if it does- this is a wedding not a theatrical performance.  If you want to be in the spotlight at all times land a gig in a play.

    Be happy that family and friends wish to celebrate your marriage with you and stop worrying about what the heck they are going to be wearing.

    "Love is the one thing we're capable of perceiving that transcends time and space."


  • My mom wore an off-white dress to our wedding. The world didn't end, and no one confused her as the bride. She looked beautiful and felt beautiful because she was. The pictures with us also look ethereal because we're both pale and were both wearing white dresses but have dark hair. I'm glad she wore white:

    image

    This isn't the hill to die on.

    Gorgeous photo!  You guys look fantastic.

    "Love is the one thing we're capable of perceiving that transcends time and space."


  • jojobrn said:
    My wedding must be invalid then because my mom write off white as well. Trust that no one thought she was the one getting married and my mom looked fantastic.

    I guess this means you get a do over!
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I second the sticky! FYI both my mom and fmil asked what they should wear originally we thought it would be cool if my mom matched the bridesmaids slightly and fmil would wear silver with the gm but she wasn't digging the silver so we said it really doesn't matter what color as long as she's happy. My mom though liked the idea of wearing green and actually wants to make her own dress :)
  • KatWAG said:

    You don't get to tell any of your guests how to dress. It is rude and very controlling. FMIL clearly likes her off white dress and she is having money issue. Stop making an issue out of this. You dont want to hurt your relationship with your FMIL.

    The thing is, she doesn't have a money issue...FI was able to talk to her and she told him she is causing this to get a rise out of me because its not her day and she wants things her way. We are paying for everything and she has been very demanding since day one. She doesn't seem to get that she doesn't pay she has no say. Only reason a reminder went out was because I was questioned by FMIL. I spoke with her and told her that I have been very accomodating to her demands and the one thing that I have asked for her to do is to not wear that dress. She tried to tell me its a money issue and when I told her to cut the crap and I know the truth she stopped in her tracks. She said she will find another dress. She said she was wrong and apologized.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    Michelle & Ronald
    01/03/81
    06/18/81
    08/25/10
    05/07/13
    03/15/14

    image172 Invites sent
    image 132 adults and 3 kids are party animals
    image 40 are party poopers
    image 0 awaiting reply
    Need 8 adults to make minimum.  Eek.
  • so this was all made up drama?

    image
    image
  • oh and to add, I really don't care what color her dress is so long as its not cream/off white/ivory/white. I am not that demanding and haven't been, where as she has. Only reason why she's been apart of wedding stuff is because FI has invited her. From this point forward she is not included until the day of.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    Michelle & Ronald
    01/03/81
    06/18/81
    08/25/10
    05/07/13
    03/15/14

    image172 Invites sent
    image 132 adults and 3 kids are party animals
    image 40 are party poopers
    image 0 awaiting reply
    Need 8 adults to make minimum.  Eek.
  • SBminiSBmini member
    500 Love Its 1000 Comments Second Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited January 2014
    I think it definitely says something about your FMIL that she would choose to wear white to both her children's weddings. But that's on her. I would let it go and move on. She'll be the one who looks silly, not you.

    image
  • Wow I can just feel all of the love! I'm sorry OP if your fmil is really giving you a hard time but you catch more flies with honey. I'm going to be honest and the way you responded to her if that's in fact how you responded sounds unnecessarily rude over a tiny issue.
  •  I am not that demanding and haven't been, where as she has.
    Wait, what?  I am reading that you are demanding that she not wear white/off white/cream  and you are not letting it go because she is "not allowed."  How is that not demanding?
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards