Hello all!
I recently got engaged in May and my fiancé and I want nothing more than a Florida Keys wedding in either Jan, Feb, or March of 2015 (we would do 2014 but it's too short of notice).
Unlike most couples who plan Florida Keys weddings as destination weddings, I'm actually a South Florida native.
I have some venues in mind for both the ceremony and reception together but I'd love recommendations for possible Catholic churches (in case I decide to have a full church ceremony), trustworthy vendors, and any other venues I may have missed.
I have my heart set on Key West but if there are any other venues on the other keys that come highly recommended for the right price I could be more flexible.
I intend on traveling to the Keys to check out each and every one as soon as this horrible rain decides to let off.
My dream ceremony & reception venue: Southernmost Mansion in Key West (I have emailed them multiple times for an RFP but have gotten no reply.

)
Other venues:
Key West Lighthouse
Hemingway House
The Reach (Waldorf Astoria) [pricey]
Hawks Cay (Duck Key) [pricey]
Thank you for any and all advice and/or recommendations!
-Jess
Re: Florida Keys Wedding: Recommendations/Advice Wanted!
I'm having my wedding at The Reach in September and I am so happy about the decision. I didn't feel that it was more expensive than most. I felt the location is truly unique (the gazebo is amazing)! If you have a chance you should visit, Nicole is great!
Hawk's Cay is pretty but I didn't like the setting as much as different locations in the Keys.