That's not what a bridal shower is for. Unfortunately, in this case, the bride should decline any offers of a bridal shower. If anyone does ask what they'd like, feel free to say they're saving for a honeymoon.
Unfortunately, that's not my decision to make. The bride is a friend who WANTS a shower…to see her family and celebrate together. However, she and her fiancé have a home together. What they NEED is donations for a honeymoon.
Unfortunately, that's not my decision to make. The bride is a friend who WANTS a shower…to see her family and celebrate together. However, she and her fiancé have a home together. What they NEED is donations for a honeymoon.
No one needs a honeymoon. They want one and should pay for it themselves.
Unfortunately, that's not my decision to make. The bride is a friend who WANTS a shower…to see her family and celebrate together. However, she and her fiancé have a home together. What they NEED is donations for a honeymoon.
Fortunately, you posted your question on an etiquette board, so everyone here will answer with proper etiquette. In fact, it is your decision to make, unless the bride is forcing you to host a shower at gunpoint (in this case, you should consult the police, not an etiquette board). She should not be requesting a shower at all. A shower is a gift offered, not owed or demanded.
there is no polite way to say that at all. Asking for cash is rude no matter what way you say it. Bridal Showers are gift-giving events, so if there are no "gifts" to shower you with then there should not be a bridal shower.
The best way for Bride to get cash for the honeymoon politely is to not register or have a small registry and most people will get the hint that they do not need much and they will then choose to give you cash or they still may choose to get a gift when they come to the wedding. It is OK to have "word of mouth" if someone asks, that bride and groom are saving for a honeymoon but do not straight out write that on the invitation.
We were saving for a house prior to the wedding. We set up a smaller registry with things we needed and could use for the house and got many nice gifts at my bridal shower. Anybody who asked us directly or asked my mom/MIL,etc what to get us for the wedding we/they informed people we were saving money to move into a house. About 80% of the wedding gifts we received were monetary.
Then it would be better to do a luncheon. The bride can want what she wants, but cash showers are unbelievably rude, and I for one, would never want to embarrass myself or my friend/relative by helping to host such a rude thing.The point of them again, is to "shower" the bride with gifts. There's no polite way to open cash/checks in front of people-again the point of a shower. Have a money shower and most people will find reasons to decline.
Your friend is not a charity. She does not "NEED" donations. Asking for cash is extremely inappropriate. Just because your friend wants a cash shower, which makes no sense, does not mean you should condone her bad manners. If you are hosting the shower then you DO get to decide that what she is asking for is just plain rude.
Suggestions for how to word on a bridal shower invitation that the bride would prefer a cash donation for her honeymoon rather than an actual gift?
@Sarandon2013 also said......Unfortunately, that's not my decision to make. The bride is a friend who WANTS a shower…to see her family and celebrate together. However, she and her fiancé have a home together. What they NEED is donations for a honeymoon.
A cash shower does not exist. If your friend wants to see her family and celebrate together as such, she can just wait for the wedding. She is having a wedding, isn't she?
@sarandon2013, tell the bride that if she wants cash only, she needs to forgo a shower. Showers are for the giving and opening of boxed or wrapped gifts, not cash. It's not the guests' job to fund her honeymoon.
Showers are to "shower the bride" with gifts to help setup the new home. If you don't need help with setting up the new home logic says forgo the shower. Instead the entitlement world we live in these days want people to give them cash for vacations instead.
No, it should not work that way. I would absolutely refused to attend a "shower me with cash" shower.
For the record, I'm a gift for the shower, cash for the wedding person. I also owned my own home when I got married yet was still managed to find things to registry for my 30 person GIFT shower. I also recieved a few wonderful, thoughtful physical non-registered gifts that I treasure to this day. We got 95% cash for the wedding. I don't have the same feelings looking at the things we bought with the wedding cash that I do for the physical gifts.
What differentiates an average host and a great host is anticipating unexpressed needs and wants of their guests. Just because the want/need is not expressed, doesn't mean it wouldn't be appreciated.
Wow, guys. Okay, point has been made! Got the message loud and clear. I appreciate the feedback and we'll definitely go in another direction. Let's end the thread here. Signing off...
Unfortunately, that's not my decision to make. The bride is a friend who WANTS a shower…to see her family and celebrate together. However, she and her fiancé have a home together. What they NEED is donations for a honeymoon.
Tell your friend she is making an etiquette mistake and she is likely to anger her friends and family that she sooo wants to gather
FWIW, I agree that cash showers are unbelieveably rude. No one NEEDS a honeymoon. If you do throw one, both you and the bride will be judged heavily for it, and it's likely that most people or no one will come. If they do, they won't give cash.
If you do want to have an event for her, a luncheon, brunch, or tea would all be very appropriate, non-gift (of any kind) events.
The bride has no right to ask for a shower, or to control anything about the shower except the potential guest list. She can ask you to do whatever, but you don't have to go along with it. Do you WANT to give her a shower? You sounded like you didn't. If you do want to give her a shower, make your own plans, co-ordinate the date and guest list, but if she talks about gifts, just say, "Oh, I think we'll just surprise you. That is half the fun of shower, isn't it?" If she presses you about wanted money, just say, "I'm sorry, but that isn't what we are doing." Then bean dip her. You might suggest that she signs up here on The Knot, herself. We'll set her straight! After all, SHE is the one who is out of line, not you!
FWIW, I agree that cash showers are unbelieveably rude. No one NEEDS a honeymoon. If you do throw one, both you and the bride will be judged heavily for it, and it's likely that most people or no one will come. If they do, they won't give cash.
If you do want to have an event for her, a luncheon, brunch, or tea would all be very appropriate, non-gift (of any kind) events.
This, definitely. You can have a tea or luncheon as a way for everyone to celebrate together (assuming all that are invited are also invited to the wedding).
I'm usually a shower gift / wedding money type as well. And in general, when I end up not going to a shower / there isn't a shower, I find myself giving extra on the wedding gift itself since there was no shower gift to eat away at my present budget. And if I was invited to a nice hosted luncheon where gifts weren't expected, I'd probably go even higher on the wedding present. Not everyone is like that, but I'm sure some are (or am I just crazy?). So it's definitely possible that she'd still get at least some of that extra honeymoon money anyway.
Assuming she doesn't register anywhere most guests will likely give cash anyway. It will work out (but for all that is good and merciful... if you catch wind that she's planning on putting anything about [money] gifts / honeyfund / etc on the wedding invitations, threaten to chain yourself to the mailbox so she can't).
Who cares if CMGr answered with sarcasm? It was to illustrate the absurdity of the bride wanting a cash shower.
RebeccaB88 said she didn't see any so I just pointed out what might qualify as such. Also, clearly the OP cared otherwise she wouldn't have mentioned it.
Yeah, I realize the OP cared. My point was that it's perfectly fine to have replied with sarcasm considering the point was to call attention to the absurdity of the bride's shower request.
What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
I was in the same position as your friend. DH and I had a home together and didn't need anything but my mom and sister wanted to throw a shower.
We compromised and had a "bridal luncheon". I did not register and the invitations stated luncheon, not shower. Honestly, most people have cash and we received a few boxed gifts.
Have a bridal luncheon or tea, which does not outright ask for gifts.
Never OK to ask for money. Everyone knows cash is a good gift, but showers are generally for physical gifts.
The only way to hint that cash is preferred is, as said, to create a very small registry with a few items (as there are people who only give physical gifts, including at the wedding). People will get the hint.
Re: Cash Gift Etiquette
The best way for Bride to get cash for the honeymoon politely is to not register or have a small registry and most people will get the hint that they do not need much and they will then choose to give you cash or they still may choose to get a gift when they come to the wedding. It is OK to have "word of mouth" if someone asks, that bride and groom are saving for a honeymoon but do not straight out write that on the invitation.
We were saving for a house prior to the wedding. We set up a smaller registry with things we needed and could use for the house and got many nice gifts at my bridal shower. Anybody who asked us directly or asked my mom/MIL,etc what to get us for the wedding we/they informed people we were saving money to move into a house. About 80% of the wedding gifts we received were monetary.
No, it should not work that way. I would absolutely refused to attend a "shower me with cash" shower.
For the record, I'm a gift for the shower, cash for the wedding person. I also owned my own home when I got married yet was still managed to find things to registry for my 30 person GIFT shower. I also recieved a few wonderful, thoughtful physical non-registered gifts that I treasure to this day. We got 95% cash for the wedding. I don't have the same feelings looking at the things we bought with the wedding cash that I do for the physical gifts.
FWIW, I agree that cash showers are unbelieveably rude. No one NEEDS a honeymoon. If you do throw one, both you and the bride will be judged heavily for it, and it's likely that most people or no one will come. If they do, they won't give cash.
If you do want to have an event for her, a luncheon, brunch, or tea would all be very appropriate, non-gift (of any kind) events.
I think this qualifies as sarcasm.
The bride has no right to ask for a shower, or to control anything about the shower except the potential guest list. She can ask you to do whatever, but you don't have to go along with it.
Do you WANT to give her a shower? You sounded like you didn't.
If you do want to give her a shower, make your own plans, co-ordinate the date and guest list, but if she talks about gifts, just say, "Oh, I think we'll just surprise you. That is half the fun of shower, isn't it?" If she presses you about wanted money, just say, "I'm sorry, but that isn't what we are doing." Then bean dip her.
You might suggest that she signs up here on The Knot, herself. We'll set her straight! After all, SHE is the one who is out of line, not you!
This, definitely. You can have a tea or luncheon as a way for everyone to celebrate together (assuming all that are invited are also invited to the wedding).
I'm usually a shower gift / wedding money type as well. And in general, when I end up not going to a shower / there isn't a shower, I find myself giving extra on the wedding gift itself since there was no shower gift to eat away at my present budget. And if I was invited to a nice hosted luncheon where gifts weren't expected, I'd probably go even higher on the wedding present.
Not everyone is like that, but I'm sure some are (or am I just crazy?). So it's definitely possible that she'd still get at least some of that extra honeymoon money anyway.
Assuming she doesn't register anywhere most guests will likely give cash anyway. It will work out (but for all that is good and merciful... if you catch wind that she's planning on putting anything about [money] gifts / honeyfund / etc on the wedding invitations, threaten to chain yourself to the mailbox so she can't).
Good luck!
RebeccaB88 said she didn't see any so I just pointed out what might qualify as such. Also, clearly the OP cared otherwise she wouldn't have mentioned it.
We compromised and had a "bridal luncheon". I did not register and the invitations stated luncheon, not shower. Honestly, most people have cash and we received a few boxed gifts.