October 2012 Weddings

Grandmother's Dress- What's your take on this situation?

Hi Ladies,
I've fallen into a bit of a situation within my family involving my Grandmother's wedding dress.  I would LOVE your input or what you think about the situation, so here it is:

My mom is the baby of 7 kids.  My grandmother died when I was 7, but I was very close with her.  My Godfather (my uncle) has her wedding dress stored at his house, because at the time of her death, he had the most storage.  We wanted to see the dress, take some photos of it, ect.  So, my mom called my Godfather (her brother) to ask if we could borrow the dress the next time her,  my aunts and I were getting together.   My Godfather's wife calls my mom back, and told her nobody is to wear the dress, it was given to her daughter, it was ruined, they paid for it to get preserved, ect.  To keep the story a bit short, they said the only way we can see the dress is at their house, basically under their supervision.  Now, the dress was not willed to anyone, which we found out, and so now her (my Godfather's wife) story is they asked for it before my Grandmother died when her daughter was 5.  To me, that seems odd because why would one of my youngest cousins get the dress, and not the oldest girl (who isn't even me), and who thinks to ask for your own mother's wedding dress? It's not like she was ill.

So, one of my mom's sisters wrote them a letter, stating how it's ridiculous how we can't see the dress, and I aslo wrote a letter to him asking if I could see the dress, and how much it would mean for me to see it, and I was ignored.  No response, no phone call, nothing. 

I really dont think it's a big deal to let me borrow the dress.  I am planning on giving it back if I get to see it, but I feel that seeing her dress is one of the little ways she can be "a part" of my wedding.

So whats your input on this?
Thanks for listening!!!!!!

Re: Grandmother's Dress- What's your take on this situation?

  • I don't understand why they care if you see and take photos of the dress? In your post you say you want to see it and then give it back, right?

    I could understand if you were saying that you were going to chop the dress up and make it something totally different (which is what I did with my Mom's dress - with her permission), but it doesn't sound like that's your intention.

    Sounds like they are overreacting.

    172 Invited. image
    130 Accepted. image
    42 Declined. image
    0 Can't find the mailbox. imageWedding Countdown Ticker
  • So, first I agree with above. If all you want to do is see I don't understand their problem.

    On the flip side, if they are being this childish over it, and you only want to see it for the sake of seeing it (you didn't really define WHY you want to see it) that I'd just drop it.

    Are there pictures of her in the dress around?

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    October 13, 2012
  • Seeing the dress came up  because my other grandmother pulled hers out because she thought it would be fun for me to see.  So from that, I thought " I wonder about Nana's dress."  NEVER in a million years did I think asking to see it would create such drama.  It's just gotten to the point where my mom is more upset becasue her brothers wife is holding her own mother's dress "hostage".   I am not doing anything with the dress, I am giving it back (if I ever get to see it) and her stuff is supposed to travel between her 7 kids.....But I do want to see it for the sake of just seeing it.  I am a prettty sentimental person, and it would mean a lot to me if it was possible to look at it.  And I would go to their house and see it, but they are (way) less than welcoming.
    Thank you for the input!
  • Agreed with PPs, they are being ridiculous, and I understand your wanting to see it.

    The part that is jumping out to me from the original post tho.... it was ruined? Did someone ruin the dress at some point?
  • I truly don't think the dress is damaged.  I think it was one of the first excuses of why I can't see it, becasue in the next sentence she said it was preserved and didn't want it taken out.  And just FYI, we also offered to pay to get it re-preserved.
  • Ok, that's interesting... Maybe something did happen tho and they're afraid of other people seeing it and getting upset. That's what I was thinking when I first saw that.

    All in all I think the situation sucks and they are being childish, I would try to let it go just so bigger problems aren't caused.
  • I was thinking on the lines of lepoissonrouge, where maybe someone, or maybe even she, ruined the dress and they dont want to show it or admit it.

    It is very sad that they are acting like this, how pathetic of them. I really hope that things work out and they let you see it and take pictures. I would try to call and talk to your uncle only. It wasnt her mom, so I dont understand why she has all this control. Maybe she did do something to the dress.

    Anywho, I am so sorry this is happening. My grandmother means the world to me, so I would be devestated.
    weddingpic
  • I thnk the PP have got it all figured out but I just have to say sorry that you're dealing with all of this.  Sucks when family can be worse than strangers!!
    my_wedding_original Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited April 2012
    I'm thinking along the lines of a few PP except one step further....I don't think they have the dress anymore.  Its pretty sketchy behavior and it seems like they are giving you excuse after excuse.

    Sorry to hear you have to deal with this...good luck and keep us posted.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Their whole story sounds fishy.  I agree, that something did happen to the dress and they don't want to admit it.  It was ruined but they had it preserved??  I also find it very odd that your aunt (who would be the daughter-in-law, correct?) asked her mother-in-law for her wedding dress for her daughter?  Usually its the other way around...the dress goes to the daughter's, daughter.  They're obviously hiding something, I'd be pissed if it was me!!

    Sorry you have to go through all that mess.  I hope it all turns out well.  Its a shame that they have upset your mother as well.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Thank you so much for all your input and well wishes!  I will lt y'all know if I end up getting to see it!  Honestly, just the comments from all of you made me feel so much better!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards