I would love to hear how you did it, if anyone has returned an engagement ring to Kay Jewelers outside the 60-day deadline. Here's my story:
My fiance bought me a beautiful 1-carat solitaire engagement ring back in July 2015. The stone was gorgeous and sparkly and had no dark spots that you could see with your naked eye. He had spent hours in the store the day he bought it, painstakingly inspecting diamond after diamond until he found one perfect enough for me. I wore it for 2 weeks when one of the prongs broke and the stone fell out.
I was devastated, but luckily he had bought the insurance and Kay promised to replace the stone within 6 weeks. We waited, and didn't hear from the store. When it became 7 weeks, my fiance called to inquire when the ring would be ready and they said they didn't know, but they would check with their corporate office in Ohio. This was frustration #1, that it wasn't ready on time.
Finally, around the 8-week mark, they called him in to pick up the ring. He took one look at the new stone, with his naked eye (not the microscope thing) and said no way. This stone had a huge inclusion right smack in the middle of it!! Frustration #2, a diamond not remotely comparable to the original.
So they said they'd send it back again and we'd have to wait another "six weeks". It's now February 2016 and I still don't have my engagement ring back. From the time the prong broke, it's been 6 months. We already got married! I DIDN'T HAVE MY RING ON MY WEDDING DAY. The ultimate frustration and reason the ring needs to be returned and a full refund given to my husband.
Neither of us want to deal with Kay Jewelers the rest of my life, so we asked if we could return the ring since at this point we haven't actually held possession of it for more than 60 days. They said no, the 60-day return policy holds whether you have the ring or not. My fiance has already paid it off, so I'm thinking there's little chance of getting his hard-earned money back now that they have it in their hands.
There HAS to be some kind of loophole, some way to return this ring? I plan to try once more calling them myself, and if that doesn't work then I'm calling my lawyer. Just hoped someone here might have advice?