I really liked the first one. I haven't watched the second one yet.
I can't remember where, but I read something that suggested that the Roanoke story may not be the entire season, that there might be a few different stories. All the theme secrecy has me unable to figure it out.
I watched both episodes last night and have the rest of the season set to DVR. OMG. So good.
The format threw me for a loop for a minute too, V. But I really like it now that I understand. It reminds me a lot of Murder House, which is still my favorite season to date.