Wedding Woes

I've been this friend and you have to choose your boundaries.

Dear Prudence,

My best friend is back on with her on-again, off-again partner of a little over two years. He is manipulative and gaslighting, and they have no life values and priorities in common. Once, when she tried to end things in the past, he said, “You only think you want that because you’ve been talking to your friends, like [me], too much.” I really thought the last break up was going to be the one that stuck. I’m worried if I remind her of how miserable he made her, I will lose my best friend. (I’ve spent many evenings comforting her while she sobs about how a relationship shouldn’t feel like this and how she dreads a future where she spends the rest of her life feeling like this. I also have a two-page note from her about all the things she was going to remind herself of if she was ever tempted to call him again.) I’m also worried I’ll lose her if I leave her in this relationship. He knows I don’t think he’s good for her, apparently, and I find him impossible to even make small talk to. Is my best friend gone from my life for good?

—Gone for Good?

Re: I've been this friend and you have to choose your boundaries.

  • CharmedPamCharmedPam member
    Tenth Anniversary 5000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited July 2021
    This has always been tough for me. I have a friend like this but in a 10+ sour relationship who refuses to kick her guy out… there’s legit nothing I can say that will make her do it, so now I’m just support for her.  She complains about him daily.  To bad there’s nothing she can do about it (sarcastic). 

  • AH like this will be divisive and pull her away.  I agree you need to choose boundaries and also need to figure out what kind of friend and if you want to be that friend.   You can share your opinions but it sounds like doing that is going to drive her away.  Be careful if that's your goal. 
  • It sucks. Figure out what is a deal breaker for you first and stick to it. But it sounds like this is a toxic and potentially emotionally abusive relationship which are truly so difficult to leave. Be there for what you can and keep communication open if you can. 
  • I lost a friendship over something similar.  I was very sad to lose it, but I couldn't be there for her with this relationship.  The friend reached out, weirdly, when I was going through my divorce and we've reconnected.  She didn't stay married to the douchelord very long, but it still took time for her to reach out to me.

    You just have to choose what you're able/willing to do and be willing to deal with the consequences.
  • Overall, I think the LW should stay out of it other than to be emotional support.  BUT, she should make a copy of that letter and give it to her friend.  Saying something like, "I'm not going to nag you about this guy.  You know how I feel about him, but I don't want to lose our friendship over that.  However, here are your words.  You asked me to remind you of this, if you all got back together."

    In college, I lost my BFF because her abusive b/f didn't like me.  We reconnected about 2 years after that, which was about a year after they had broken up.

    Then I moved halfway across the country and our friendship slowly waned over the years, but I still made sure to meet up with her whenever I was back home in CA and it was always like no time had gone by.

    Then another abusive man...President Trump...put a major wedge in our friendship that I don't think can ever be mended.  We never had a fight about it.  But there's just been so much hate and ignorance on her FB page, that I can't see her as the same person anymore.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards