Wedding Woes

Online activism vs. IRL deeds.

Dear Prudence,

I know this is a ridiculous question but bear with me. Is it ok to not use my social media to post about activism, racial justice, etc.?

I (a white woman) work at a pro-racial-justice nonprofit (and have done so my entire career), actively making decisions in my own life—schools, neighborhoods, houses of worship, etc.—to live my values. I have generally used social media to stay connected with folks and share more personal updates about my non-work life. Last summer, I began feeling guilty that I didn’t engage in public activism on my social media. I follow a number of activist accounts, but don’t share or broadcast this. The guilt pushed me to post more actively about racial justice. But every time I posted, it was never just the right thing—folks on both sides of the political spectrum sent me messages nitpicking my phrasing or what I chose to share/not share, and I constantly felt angry and on edge. I also engaged less in in-person conversations because I was so jaded by the “unproductivity” of these online conversations.

I pulled way back from social media and have now resumed posting only personal updates. I feel happier and more centered. I have some friends who continually post about activist causes and have included phrases like “white silence is violence,” calling out white folks who post about mundane day-to-day content while activist issues are in need of amplification. I feel 100 percent okay with myself and my choices until I see these sorts of posts. Can you help me settle this within myself, once and for all: Is it ok for me not to use my social media accounts to post activist content?

— Activist, But Offline

Re: Online activism vs. IRL deeds.

  • You’re not silent, you’re very vocally and physically showing up in ways that matter. That’s real life, not social media stances. 
  • I'm generally not a big fan of turning my FB into any platform other than "This is what we're doing".  In the same vein, I question the motives by the people I know who donate and constantly post that they donate.  Be a good person.  
  • I can honestly say I do what I can in person vs what I share on social media.
    I share information but it's not real life.
  • This might be an UO, but I think too much of our society is WAY too wrapped up in social media.

    It's at alarming levels and I think is doing a lot of damage to our society.  More then people even realize.

    Don't get me wrong, there are "pros" to social media.  It certainly isn't all bad.  But I'm really disturbed by people who seem to live their whole lives on social media and where that is their identity.  Who worry about "look at my selfie with a world famous painting in the background", instead of...looking at the masterpiece.  Marveling in its history and letting it touch their soul.  But hey, I got 2,034 "likes" for this post.  That's my best yet.  Gag. 

    At any rate, this letter is a good example of what I am talking about.  The LW is judged if they write activism posts.  Judged if they don't write activism posts, as if they "owe" any particular cause their time and mental energy for social media posts.  

    It's also possible to live your life completely off social media, ((pearl clutch!!!)).  I know.  Shocking.  I have a FB account I look at about once a week and no other SM accounts.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • This might be an UO, but I think too much of our society is WAY too wrapped up in social media.


    I'm not sure who finds that an u/o, lol.  But yeah, so many people live very online.  I don't engage in debate about anything serious on social media very often because there's no nuance and I'm honestly scared of online harassment.   I very much support outspoken IDGAF people, but I much prefer talking IRL to people or in a one on one messaging situation. 
  • mrsconn23 said:
    This might be an UO, but I think too much of our society is WAY too wrapped up in social media.


    I'm not sure who finds that an u/o, lol.  But yeah, so many people live very online.  I don't engage in debate about anything serious on social media very often because there's no nuance and I'm honestly scared of online harassment.   I very much support outspoken IDGAF people, but I much prefer talking IRL to people or in a one on one messaging situation. 
    Thanks, lol.  I feel like it is because I see so many people who are obsessed with it.  And I don't usually see that much caution or negativity about it.

    Like most things, it's about moderation.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • What you do in real life will ultimately have more impact than anything you could post on social media, or at least I think it will. Try to remember that. 

    Also, taking care of yourself and your mental health can include deciding what how you engage (and don't engage) on social media. Wading into politics and controversial issues on those platforms can get overwhelming and draining, and it's okay to stay out of it if you think that's what's best for you. 
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards