Last week I was excited that their heated blankets were on clearance. I added two to my registry (so I could get the additional 15% completion discount) and then put them in my online cart.
I applied a $25 gift card and all of our registry rewards, about $56, and put the balance on my Macy's card ($29.62). I was so excited.
I hadn't received a shipping notification so when I logged into my account today I noticed they were still in my shopping cart and my gift card balances were no longer applied. I had thrown the cards away thinking they were all used up.

I'm chatting online with a Macy's chat representative and I don't think there is anything they can do. Totally sucks.
Re: Just sick... Lost my Macy's gift cards. :(
I don't suppose you can search through the garbage for them?
Oh wow, that's terrible.
Did you get the order notification when you originally placed it? That should have the payment breakdown for the order.
Also, I love electric blankets. My mom buys us one every Christmas as a gift.