Dear Prudence,
A new colleague was recently transferred to my department at work. While she’s great at the job, she has a habit that drives me up a wall. Every time someone shares an anecdote with her, she repeats the final sentence several times in a row and riffs on it. For example, I told her about an obnoxious client, and ended the story by saying, “I’m not a fan of his.” She responded by saying, “Not a fan. Not even a little bit. Not. A. Fan. Would not cheer for his team, even if they paid me.”
I know that this rhetorical technique is probably an attempt at building rapport, but I never know what to say afterwards. It would be one thing if it happened occasionally, but it’s how she ends every. single. conversation. Any advice about how to change up this pattern? I want to connect with her better, but I find myself avoiding casual chats because of her parrot-like tendencies.
— Mimicked in Michigan