I haven't stayed at either hotel, but I grew up close by. Both hotels are owned by Calandra Enterprises and they're only 1/4 mile apart from each other.
The restaurants are both great, and I believe both hotels offer shuttles. While the Hampton Inn is newer, the Executive Inn has a strip mall next door with a few restaurants, a hair salon, florist, Calandra's bakery, etc.
We went with Fairfield Executive Inn. The big sells for us were that I think it was like $10 cheaper a night, the bar is in its own separate room (so if people want to go after the wedding, we won't feel like we're disrupting guests by being right in the lobby), and we liked the little restaurant area better.
However, they're really both very comparable and offer the same amenities.
I've not stayed in those specific hotels but I travel frequently for work and stay at both chains often. Generally, they are about the same but I tend to like the feel of Hampton Inns. I think you get a nicer breakfast there, too. For whatever that general experience is worth . . .
The prices were the same and they were both offering the same type of stuff.
I wound up going with Fairfield Executive Inn. It's not as nice on the outside but I liked that the bar and breakfast areas were seperate and not in the lobby.
I am going to check out both hotels with FI later in the month. We do have the info for the Hampton Inn so we just need to talk to someone. We are also going to look at the Crowne Plaza on 46. The hotels that are closer to the Brownstone I wasn't impressed with.
I just booked the Executive Inn for my wedding in July. I did not like Hampton Inn as much because of there poor customer service and they were not so accommodating as the Executive Inn.
The sales team at the Executive Inn are extremely helpful and nice!!
Re: Hampton Inn vs Fairfield Executive Inn?
However, they're really both very comparable and offer the same amenities.
I wound up going with Fairfield Executive Inn. It's not as nice on the outside but I liked that the bar and breakfast areas were seperate and not in the lobby.
Thanks for your help