Wedding Etiquette Forum

Bridal Shower Touchy Subject.

So... In a previous post, I explained that my mom and sister are throwing me a bridal shower, and are inviting all of my mom's cousins, and family friends, and even their friends that I'm not so close with. Because we're having a "destination wedding" in Hawaii (which, is where we reside) and because we are paying for it ourselves, we can't invite everyone to the actual wedding. I know most everyone says its a no-no to invite people to the shower, if they're not invited to the wedding. I feel like most people should understand that we simply cannot invite everyone because we just don't have the money and that we're already over out set budget. But I'm also sure some people would be offended. However, the problem is... my mom and sister already bought the invitations that say "bridal shower"... so we can't say its a engagement party or a luncheon. My sister said its my fault because we're the ones paying for the wedding, and because I'm the one who's not inviting these people. She said that I should explain that everyone isn't invited to the wedding at the shower. But to me- I couldn't care less if the people who aren't coming to the wedding come to the shower or not. But mom and sis are set on the guestlist and think that people would be offended not to be invited to either. What do I do? I don't want to feel awkward at my own wedding! My sis is including our registry in the card- should I add something to say that gifts are optional since we can't invite everyone? Or invite the rest, hoping they don't come (mom says they won't)- but I'm scared that they will, and my fiance would kill me. Ugh. Sorry so long. I need advice.
Kristen
Married: May 7th, 2010
Our Pregnancy/Baby Planning Blog Our Wedding Planning Blog Coming Soon, Baby K!!
«13

Re: Bridal Shower Touchy Subject.

  • I meant... I don't want to feel awkward at my own SHOWER!
    Kristen
    Married: May 7th, 2010
    Our Pregnancy/Baby Planning Blog Our Wedding Planning Blog Coming Soon, Baby K!!
  • Don't include registry cards Tuna. Decline shower.
  • Having a DW does not entitle you to a shower with non-invited wedding guests. Say thank you and decline the shower.  You shouldn't be rude just because you are having a DW.
  • Your sister is wrong.  Her and your mom know who will and won't be invited to the wedding and are just throwing etiquette out the window by inviting people to the shower who are not invited to the wedding.  This is their faux pas, and will reflect badly on them. Don't invite more people than you can afford, whether or not they invite these people to the shower.  You have no control over the shower list and they have no control over the wedding list, no matter how hard they try pressuring you into inviting their guests.
    kd.joseph's wish is my command
    image
    Just call me "Brothel"
    And betrothed, I'm disgusted with most of the comments that you have posted. I don't think I've ever read such judgmental comments in my life. I'm so lucky that the girls I speak to on theknot are nothing like you...I would've never come on here for ADVICE if I would've encountered a big a bitch as you. I genuinely feel awful for your children or your future children, and I think it would be irresponsible of YOU not to invest in their future therapy sessions starting now. Because trust me when I tell you honey, they're gonna need it. ~jcaruncho2010
    my read shelf:
    Betrothed 123's book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • It's poor etiquette to invite people to any pre-wedding party and then not the wedding. So even if it were an engagement party, it would still be pretty tacky. You should always plan for everyone to show up, too, so don't invite anyone in the hopes they won't show. Your mom and sister screwed up big time.
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • They may even be able to return the extra invites.
  • Since you are paying, stand your ground, do not invite the rest, just because you dont think they will come.  You have to expect 100% attendance, and I would not want to take the chance. Have you expressed you do not want them to throw you a "shower"?  I had a similar situation, FMIL invited people to the shower that aren't invited to the wedding, I expressed how I felt it was rude.  She said it was common in her circle of friends.  So since she was planning it, I dropped it.  If someone has a problem, they can take it up with her.
  • The shower is already booked. And I honestly don't understand why I have to give up having a shower (that I have my heart set on)... there has to be another way to handle this.
    Kristen
    Married: May 7th, 2010
    Our Pregnancy/Baby Planning Blog Our Wedding Planning Blog Coming Soon, Baby K!!
  • You need to put your foot down in the nicest way possible.  It's nice that your mom and your sister are throwing you a shower, but they need to respect your wishes.  Obviously you're uncomfortable because you know it's rude.  They sound pushy and it will only get worse if you don't say something now. 
  • I say since the damage has already been done.....just enjoy your shower and if questions come up, address them to your sister or mother.  I would not invite the rest of the people just because.  You don't want to get yourself in more of a mess then it already has become.
  • Seriously?  You don't know why you should decline the shower?You are having a DW and a small guestlist.  You cannot invite anyone to the shower that isn't invited to the wedding.  You can have a shower but if I were you I wouldn't participate in something as rude as your mom and sister want to do.  It will reflect badly on you as well as them.Basicially, unless your sister/mom are going to only send invites to invited wedding guests I would decline instead of looking like someone that just wants presents.If I got invited to a shower and showed up, with gift in hand, and wasn't invited to the wedding I'd be pissed.
  • And I honestly don't understand why I have to give up having a shower (that I have my heart set on)...Because you decided to have a wedding in a state where only the two of you live.  A state that also happens to be quite expensive to fly in and out of.You're more than welcome to invite the people you invited to the wedding, but you cannot invite folks that you didn't invite to the wedding.  When you choose to have a very small wedding, you are also choosing to forgo some of the stuff that comes with bigger weddings - be it a rehearsal dinner, a bachelorette party, or a bridal shower.  You cannot, however, have everything you want just because you "have your heart set on it".  Life doesn't work like that. 
    image

    If I wanted to hear the pitter-patter of little feet, I'd put shoes on the cat. image

  • Okay it sounds like you want to get all the gifts. You haven't invited these people to your wedding and should not ask them to buy a gift for your shower.If you don't want to get rid of your shower, go ahead and have one but only people invited to the wedding should be invited.
  • I had my heart set on a pony when I was a little kid but I'm still waiting for my dad to buy it for me. We don't always get what we want. 
  • Might I also add, I think its completely disgusting the way you're saying that you didn't have enough money to invite them to the wedding, but that you'll be upset if you can't have a party where the people you didn't want to spend money on for the wedding can't come and lavish you with gifts to commemorate the wedding that they weren't invited to.  You sound whiny and gift-grabby.
    image

    If I wanted to hear the pitter-patter of little feet, I'd put shoes on the cat. image

  • I've argued with them already. Such a pain, really. To my FI and I, this is NOT a destination wedding. This is our home. I want all of the people to be a part of our wedding, even if we can't invite them. I'm def not in it for the gifts- to me, its a nice bonus. No one thinks that adding along with the shower invite, we add that gifts are optional, would help? I really want a shower. It would kill me to not have that tradition to go along with my wedding. I think its unfair to have to give it up because we can't afford to have everyone come to Hawaii. I already feel like we're giving up a lot by paying for it all on our own, but not having the wedding here is not an option.
    Kristen
    Married: May 7th, 2010
    Our Pregnancy/Baby Planning Blog Our Wedding Planning Blog Coming Soon, Baby K!!
  • [i]I really want a shower. It would kill me to not have that tradition to go along with my wedding.[/i] [img]<a href="http://wiki.urbandead.com/images/a/a7/Drama_Llama.jpg" rel='nofollow'>http://wiki.urbandead.com/images/a/a7/Drama_Llama.jpg</a>[/img]
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • If you don't want to get rid of your shower, go ahead and have one but only people invited to the wedding should be invited. THIS.  I don't think you have to forgo a shower entirely, but it certainly can't be bigger than your wedding.  If you're having a small invute list, then you have a small shower.
    Kailyn Jean Born August 6, 2011 (3w6d early) imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker Planning Bio
  • Decline the shower or only invite those who are invited to the wedding.It's not that complicated.
  • It would kill me to not have that tradition to go along with my weddingNice drama.
  • but not having the wedding here is not an option. Just wondering...why not?
    Kailyn Jean Born August 6, 2011 (3w6d early) imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker Planning Bio
  • You made a choice to have a DW with limited guests.By doing that you also made the choice to limit the shower guest list to those you're inviting to the wedding.That's just basic etiquette my dear.  It's not about what you want.  It's about treating others well.  Just about the worst thing you can do when planning a wedding is to invite people to the shower who you have no intention of inviting to the wedding.  If you're aware of this, your options are to change your wedding plans to include these guests or to decline the shower. Sure you have the option of having the shower but to do that is to knowingly engage in extremely rude behavior.
  • It will "kill" you to not  have this?I think you're not understanding logic here.  Also, the DW is what it means for the guests.  If you choose to live in a location that is not close to your guests and that location is where the wedding will be held then yes, it most certainly is a destination wedding.
  • Sometimes I think posting here is a mistake. Instead of people helping, sometimes people get very rude. I asked for advice, not a bunch of grief. I'm not gift-grabby whatsoever. Thanks for all that helped.
    Kristen
    Married: May 7th, 2010
    Our Pregnancy/Baby Planning Blog Our Wedding Planning Blog Coming Soon, Baby K!!
  • "By doing that you also made the choice to limit the shower guest list to those you're inviting to the wedding." I already said I'm fine doing this... my family is the one that isn't.
    Kristen
    Married: May 7th, 2010
    Our Pregnancy/Baby Planning Blog Our Wedding Planning Blog Coming Soon, Baby K!!
  • Sorry we didn't stroke your hair and tell you everything was just fine with what you are doing!!
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • Humble, I thought you said that you wanted the shower and it would kill you not to have one because you deserve to have one??
  • To my FI and I, this is NOT a destination wedding. Good for you.  To everyone else, it is.  Try thinking outside of your little box for a while.  I wouldn't expect people not to think of my wedding as a destination wedding if I was living in France just because I was living in France.I really want a shower. It would kill me to not have that tradition to go along with my wedding.No it wouldn't.  It would be disappointing, but I'm sure your vital signs will all still be there if you don't get a shower.  I really want a honeymoon in Greece.  Fishy really wants a margarita IV. Can't always get what you want.I already feel like we're giving up a lot by paying for it all on our own, but not having the wedding here is not an option. I really wish you could hear yourself.  You're refusing to have your wedding someplace that is easier for your guests to come to, you're refusing to do anything to make the wedding cheaper for you and allow more guests to come, you're bemoaning about how much you've given up for your wedding....lots of people pay for their wedding on their own.  They still are able to invite the people they want to be there.  They find ways to make it work.  I'm curious how much your budget for your wedding was.
    image

    If I wanted to hear the pitter-patter of little feet, I'd put shoes on the cat. image

  • Maybe you should just wait and post again when TK creates a "Validation" board.  Then everyone can tell you how great an idea it is to offend people by having them give you gifts and then not invite them to the wedding.Putting "gifts optional" on an invite for a shower (the very definition of which is a gift-giving party), especially an invite that is including registry information, is the most ridiculous cop-out I have ever heard.  Nobody would show up without a gift.
  • Here's the deal:Tell your family that you're really uncomfortable inviting people to a shower who will not be invited to the wedding.  Give them a copy of the wedding list. If they decide to invite people to the shower who are not invited to the wedding, and someone asks you about it, tell them to discuss it with your mom and/or sister. I believe this was mentioned as an option before.  Why haven't you acknowledged this?
    Kailyn Jean Born August 6, 2011 (3w6d early) imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker Planning Bio
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards