Earn cash as you plan. Get a $20 gift card for every 200 points with The Knot Rewards
Wedding Etiquette Forum
Controversial Topic, what do you think?
Morning ladies. I am home sick and watching The View. One of their hot topics was about a lesbian couple who wanted their child to attend a Catholic school. From what I understand, the child had been attending the school, but was not allowed to advance to the next grade and was kicked out because her mothers are lesbians.
What do you think about this?
Is the Church in the wrong?
Or should the parents of the child have anticipated this, since the institution is religious in nature?
This discussion has been closed.
Re: Controversial Topic, what do you think?
Married!
I understand that it is the chruch's prerogative on whom they can and do admit. However, there is no way they wouldn't have known the child's parents are lesbians before the child even entered the school. Think about all the forms that get filled out, think about the way preschools are set up... wouldn't both of the parents have attended meetings and openhouses? Spoken with the administrators? If they weren't going to let her in, they should have done that prior to admitting the student, and not deciding later.
I'm not sure it should have been unexpected.
That said, I feel like if the school offered quality education, they are punishing something the child can't control - her parents being lesbians. And I don't think that's fair.
Plus, Catholic schools HAVE to adhere to the rules of the diocese or they lose funding. I went to Catholic school and they taught abstinence education, including no masturbation, in religion class. I can remember at one point my teacher kind of let it known discreetly that masturbation is a safer alternative for releasing sexual tension as a teenager than other forms of sexual gratification with a partner.
Nose Job Blog
Something similar happened to my friend. She and her husband had their kids enrolled in Catholic school. Long story short, her and her abusive husband get divorced and when she applied for financial aid help to keep her children in school they wouldn't help her. The Catholic school system didn't agree with her divorce and wouldn't support her. So not only were her children having to deal with the divorce, they were also forced to switch schools. It was pretty awful.
[QUOTE]I'm actually not sure if private institutions do have that right to reject a child from their school for that reasoning. I'm not sure if it would hold up in a court of law. Something similar happened to my friend. She and her husband had their kids enrolled in Catholic school. Long story short, her and her abusive husband get divorced and when she applied for financial aid help to keep her children in school they woudln't help her. The Catholic school system didn't agree with her divorce and wouldn't support her. So not only were her children having to deal with the divorce, they were also forced to switch schools. It was pretty awful.
Posted by L-Bride[/QUOTE]
This is crazy to me. I get the concept, but I went to Catholic school from K-12, and the majority of my friends' parents were divorced.
Nose Job Blog
Is the Church in the wrong? - I think the Catholic church's stance on homosexuality is wrong, so yes.
Or should the parents of the child have anticipated this, since the institution is religious in nature? - yes, though I don't blame them for putting their child there. I don't think it was for publicity. I am not Catholic, but I attended a Catholic high school because it was a very good college prep school. I can't blame them for wanting their daughter to get a good education. I'm sure they considered the fact that something like this might come up.
Edit - I also agree that this isn't something the kid can control, so why punish her?
40/112
Really, I don't think it is a matter of the church being "close minded." The laws of the church are just that.
Either way - I think it's crappy, but I think as a religious institution, they have the right to do almost whatever they want. They should be compelled to show the child as promoted to the next grade, but then could choose not to allow her to re-enroll for the next school year.
Dresses may be easier to take in than let out, but guest lists are not. -- kate51485
[QUOTE]In Response to Re: Controversial Topic, what do you think? : This is crazy to me. I get the concept, but I went to Catholic school from K-12, and the majority of my friends' parents were divorced.
Posted by KentuckyKate[/QUOTE]
So does my sister, she has never been to public school like I went to. But I think it has to do with the school using their discretion over who they are financially helping. Since she was applying for financial aid, they said they wouldn't support her because they consider that supporting divorce. They didn't say her kids couldn't stay at the school but obviously she couldn't keep them there on her own.
I agree with squirrly, I'm surprised that the church did this. I disagree with their stance on homosexuality, and am surprised that a homosexual couple would choose to send their kids to a catholic school where their lifestyle is seen as wrong.
But I'm surprised the church would hold a child accountable for the "sins" of a parent. Eg...DH and I didn't get married in the catholic church, but if we wanted to baptize our kid in the church, they would allow it.
I went to Catholic school from 5th grade through university and I'm not Catholic and my parents are divorced (divorced when I was in 5th grade). Anyway, they sent me there because the education is second to none and the teachings, although sometimes a bit much, werent different enough from our Lutheran beliefs that it mattered.
I am still not Catholic but I plan on sending my daughter to the Catholic school in our neighborhood.
I hope, for Catholism's sake, they stop being so out of touch with society.
Even though I think it's within a religious organization's right to denounce certain behavior, I think it's absurd that homosexuality is grounds for dismissal but that so many other activities that the Bible forbids are fine and dandy (parents who commit adultery, parents who are divorced, parents who are farmers who sow multiple crops in the same field, parents who have ever experienced lustful thoughts, children who have every disobeyed/disrespected their parents, parents/children who gossip, parents/children who have ever taken the Lord's name in vain, etc. etc. etc. ETC.). According to the Bible, those are all "sins," and all "sins" are equal in the eyes of God (James 2:10). It's hypocritical.
If an institution wants to truly follow their religion to every letter, that's fine with me. But choosing one "sin" as unacceptable but looking the other way for everything else is offensive, both to the families affected as well as to the religion itself.
Rant over.
Planning!.....Married!
Featured Showing: Planning Bio-The Original
Coming Soon: Married Bio
And polichik, I completely agree. Most churches seem incredibly hypocritical in that way. But I just doubt that those parents could win in court.
At the Catholic schools here, children attend mass regularly. So, I don't see why one would send their child to a Catholic school if you aren't Catholic. Unless you don't mind your child being required to attend mass, which I think might be confusing for a child.
Poli- I see what you are saying about picking and choosing in regards to sin. Catholics recognize that everyone sins, but believe that people must repent those sins, confess, and try to do better. Homosexuals do not "repent" for their lifestyle. The Church (imho, can't speak for the whole Church obviously) basically thinks that is is better to deny homosexual urges than to choose to indulge that desire.
This isn't my personal opinion, but it is what I have gleaned from conversations with my die-hard Catholic family.
Jasmine, did the story say these people are suing the school? Because I, along with others, see them losing that one. Or was it more of a "get-the-message-out" kind of story?
40/112
One should also realize that all religion is created by man, and man is flawed. Expecting any religion to be perfect is a little ridiculous in my head. It upsets me when people choose to say that an entire religion (or Church) is wrong. That's a vast generalization. You may not agree with their beliefs, and you are not forced to believe (or practice) them.
I think one has to grow up Catholic to understand why some of the laws/rules are so strict and unchanging. And, even though I don't actively practice anymore, I feel very comforted by the unchanging nature of the Catholic church - it shows me the religion/Church is enduring and that the leaders of the religion truly believe in its principles.
Anyway...I do feel badly for this little girl and her family. I obviously don't agree with the Church on this point, and I find it horrible that they would hurt a child in this way. I think this particular school has forgotten how to be Christian.
I think that gay marriage should be legalized. One point of opposition is that legalizing gay marriage threatens Christian churches. Now, I don't believe that at all. However, if these women were to sue the church and win, it would, imo, be a step in the wrong direction, because it would be the law trying to change the practices of a certain religion. Hence, people could say, that the next step is forcing churches to marry homosexuals.
I just found it interesting, because this is a constant debate in my family. I think that marriage is a legal union, and only a spiritual union for those with spiritual beliefs.
Legally, I think at least, the school would have the right to say no to any family that isn't Catholic.
To be expected? No. Those parents should never expect such disrespect and lack of Christian love (love in general too of course) at a religious school.
I went to Catholic school for much of my education. There was a boy in the year below me whose mother was a lesbian and she had a partner. It was always known that this was his situation, although he did have a father too (they divorced obviously). His mother was in her relationship since he was a little boy and both his k-8 and our high school never treated him any differently or his moms (and dad) to my knowledge.
I think some of you guys may not be fully educated about the Catholic Church's stance. It's not that homosexual people are bad or really are any worse than anyone else. We all sin. If someone is chaste and homosexual then they are not "bad". If they act on their feelings it's the same, really, as if a heterosexual person was "unchaste". The reason why homosexual couples are frowned upon is because they are obviously acting on their feelings and being unchaste because it is outside of a religious marriage but it's the same as if any unmarried hetero couple did it. Gay marriage is wrong because it goes against, in part, what marriage is there for.
I am a practicing Catholic but I think marriage should be left to religion and the state stay completely out of it. If gay people want to be in a state "union" then I am totally down. We could use more love in the world. I understand the Church's stance, however, and appreciate that they don't change their theology willy nilly.
I'm sorry if some of you had bad experiences with the Catholic church in particular but please be mindful that these same issues happen in any kind of an organization, not just religious and certainly not just Catholic. I get quite ticked when people claim that Protestant denominations are so much more tolerant. That's not even remotely true nor should you ever make such huge generalization.
"Marriage" is primarily a legal union. It may have religious and spiritual connotations for some, but definitely not all. Concerning "marriage" I think religion should stay out of it, and the law should not be based on religious views.