I am planning a wedding in Madison, but I live out of state, so need to really limit the number of caterers I meet with/do tastings with. Three that I'm considering now are Bluephies, Circolo, and Upstairs Downstairs catering. I like the menus, but I can't find many reviews of any of them. Does anyone have any experience with any of these caterers? Alternatively, does anyone have a caterer they highly recommend (or warn against)? We're looking for something that has a bit of a creative/non-cookie cutter wedding menu, but other than that are very open.
Thanks in advance for your help!