Wedding Etiquette Forum

Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid

Hi Ladies!

It's been awhile since I've been on the knot boards!  I may be married now but so often we become involved in friend's weddings and the advice found here is still helpful!  I thought I'd leave some thoughts with you guys on getting rid of a bridesmaid.  Though I did not get rid of one, I have been the one to be ridden of, haha!


Be thoughtful of your soon-to-be-ex-BM's feelings.   She cared about you enough to decide to be your BM once, so show her the same care.  When you asked her to be one, she agreed to at least buy a dress and show up that day!

Definitely tell her (in person if you can) your change of mind!  If you...
1) asked too many people to be your BM because you were too excited or you've lost a groomsman and want to keep the sides even - tell her you made the mistake and that while she is still special to you, you are limited in the number of BM you can have. 

2) are not getting enough support from her as a BM (i.e. she's not staying involved or keeping up with what you ask) - tell her you notice that she's not available enough for what you need out of your BM's and that you don't want to be a Bridezillla who harps on her and stresses your friendship. 

3) had a huge fight or falling out with her that you do not expect to be repaired in time - tell her that the bride-BM relationship is not working out and that you need to focus on your friendship with her instead and that her being your BM right now would stress that friendship. 

But definitely talk to her about it, she may not have the $ or time (or want) to do what you need anymore and she may welcome the chance to bow out gracefully!!  Remember, she cared about you enough to be you BM in the first place so she'll understand!!


If you care,  here's my story in becoming an ex-BM Laughing

Edited for brevity:
I was asked by a dear friend to be one of her BMs shortly after her engagement.  Four months later, something came up and she no longer wanted me as a BM.
But she never said anything about it to me even though I assumed so.  I should have asked her but it seemed awkward and presumptuous to ask her something that should have been so obvious! 

Today I got my confirmation.  Just out of chance, I came across a posting from her on a knot board where she asked if cutting me and not telling me was wrong:

The only response she got?  "Good job cutting that BM loose!"

I believe the advice (or lack thereof) was bad!  And in the end it was more hurtful to me that she never told me explicitly than it would have been on hearing the news that she couldn't/didn't want to include me...
BabyFetus Ticker
«1

Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid

  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_getting-rid-of-bridesmaid?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:78947719-9794-4854-82e2-692ed3a2e84cPost:b4e4f5ce-98b7-4101-a874-18813647a93b">Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid</a>:
    [QUOTE]Hi Ladies! It's been awhile since I've been on the knot boards!  I may be married now but so often we become involved in friend's weddings and the advice found here is still helpful!  I thought I'd leave some thoughts with you guys on getting rid of a bridesmaid.  Though I did not get rid of one, I have been the one to be ridden of, haha! Be thoughtful of your soon-to-be-ex-BM's feelings.   She cared about you enough to decide to be your BM once, so show her the same care.  When you asked her to be one, she knew you were asking her to commit to: 1) being cosumed by your wedding planning, even though she may be jealous of your wedding/engagement or despise weddings in general 2) buy and wear whatever (potentially ill-fitting) $100+ dress you wanted 3) help you mail out STDs and invites or create favors 4) help/host and decorate for your shower and bachlorette party 5) take time from work or block a whole week out during her summer just for your wedding 6) do practically whatever you needed as the bride Definitely tell her (in person if you can) your change of mind!  If you... 1) asked too many people to be your BM because you were too excited or you've lost a groomsman and want to keep the sides even - tell her you made the mistake and that while she is still special to you, you are limited in the number of BM you can have.  2) are not getting enough support from her as a BM (i.e. she's not staying involved or keeping up with what you ask) - tell her you notice that she's not available enough for what you need out of your BM's and that you don't want to be a Bridezillla who harps on her and stresses your friendship.  3) had a huge fight or falling out with her that you do not expect to be repaired in time - tell her that the bride-BM relationship is not working out and that you need to focus on your friendship with her instead and that her being your BM right now would stress that friendship.  But definitely talk to her about it, she may not have the $ or time (or want) to do what you need anymore and she may welcome the chance to bow out gracefully!!  Remember, she cared about you enough to be you BM in the first place so she'll understand!! If you care,  here's my story in becoming an ex-BM :  I was asked by a dear friend to be one of her BMs shortly after her engagement.  Four months later, an unexpected falling out happened between us and I was told we could no longer be friends... oh well!  But a short timed passed and we were again talking.  Three months later we made up as friends and our friendship is almost what it was before.  When I was told we were no longer friends, I figured I was booted from her BM list.  Besides, she had an extra BM at the time and she was trying to figure out what to do with and this made the decision easy for her.  But she neve r said anything about it to me.  When our non-friendship status came and went quickly I figured she would confirm I was off the list or tell me that she got rid of the one BM she was considering removing before our fallout and that I was still in.  But she still said nothing! So was I officially cut from the BM list or was this just a little tiff between friends and I was still expected to perform my BM duties??  I should have asked her but it seemed awkward and presumptuous to ask her something that should have been so obvious!  I couldn't be 100% sure I was out since I was never told, though every day that passed it became more clear that I was totally out of the loop and, therefore, off the list.  However, I had this fear that she was again expecting me be her BM and come July 2nd, I would have no clue, no dress, and no details on what I needed to do.  As a friend I've cared about all along, I didn't want to let her down, even with our temporary fallout.  Today I got my confirmation.  Just out of chance, I came across a posting from her on a knot board where she asked a couple months back if cutting me and not telling me was wrong: "...I didn't tell her she wasn't apart of my party anymore because I figured she would be smart enough to know without me saying anything...bad?" The only response she got?  "Good job cutting that BM loose!" I appreciate the credit she gives my intelligence, haha, but the advice (or lack thereof) was bad!  And in the end it was more hurtful to me that she never told me explicitly than it would have been on hearing the news that she couldn't/didn't want to include me... I'd feel lucky to even get an invite from her now !
    Posted by ylime1207[/QUOTE]

    Thanks?
  • Wow, I cannot believe I read all of this this. I don't really get it.
  • THAT was the response she got? Not from this board. Nope.
  • At least they spelled the word "loose" right.
  • Uh, or you could just not be a jerkoff by kicking out your BM. That's way easier than reading the novel you just typed.

    Good luck! (you're welcome Annie)
    image
    Whatever you hatters be hattin. -Tay Prince
  • I didn't read this, but the subject line has me a little worried that you recently buried a body in the desert. 
    image
  • Also didn't even want to spend the time to read this.  wow!
  • Holy wall of text.  CN please? 
    Anniversary
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_getting-rid-of-bridesmaid?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:78947719-9794-4854-82e2-692ed3a2e84cPost:b4e4f5ce-98b7-4101-a874-18813647a93b">Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid</a>:
    [QUOTE]the advice (or lack thereof) was bad! 
    Posted by ylime1207[/QUOTE]

    About as bad as the... advice? you just gave?
    image
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_getting-rid-of-bridesmaid?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:9Discussion:78947719-9794-4854-82e2-692ed3a2e84cPost:b68b1dcb-8d45-4753-a7ef-6d3e3a9a0756">Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid</a>:
    [QUOTE]Holy wall of text.  CN please? 
    Posted by jemmini6[/QUOTE]

    I don't think anyone really understands what this is about. I think she was a BM, then had a fight, thought she was out but was never told she was out, friends again, still not told she was out, found a post on TK about her being kicked out. I don't really understand why this was posted though, she has no question. I think she thought The Knot was her diary.
  • Mods should be able to ban bad advice.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • Um, no.  This is bad advice.

    1.  Being a BM is not a job, it's an honor.  A BM's "job" consists of getting the required attire (with said BM's budget input), showing up to the wedding, and posing for pictures.  The rest of it isn't required...it's nice, but not required or expected.

    2.  Generally on the boards, most people will say that it's not okay to boot a BM.  I'd like to see this particular thread so we can see the circumstances as your friend posted them, but generally, most of us don't tell brides to boot BMs, even if it's for even sides.  The reason is that it's a friendship-ending move, and it makes the bride look like a tool to people in her social circle.

    However, if the friendship has ended, it's a given that the bride wouldn't want the BM in the WP.  If you fall out with someone, do you really need for the person to tell you, "oh by the way, I don't want you to be a bridesmaid anymore?"  It's common sense.

    But again, without you referring to the specific post (like including a link), people aren't going to know what you're referring to, so you're going to get a lot of confused replies.
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_getting-rid-of-bridesmaid?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:78947719-9794-4854-82e2-692ed3a2e84cPost:d80d0a7c-8b53-4687-9ec9-523b9b06a8a7">Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid</a>:
    [QUOTE]In Response to Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid : I don't think anyone really understands what this is about. I think she was a BM, then had a fight, thought she was out but was never told she was out, friends again, still not told she was out, found a post on TK about her being kicked out. I don't really understand why this was posted though, she has no question. I think she thought The Knot was her diary.
    Posted by ahhhitsshannyn[/QUOTE]

    All of that, but she posted to give a bunch of bad advice on how to properly kick out a BM.
  • *Blink, blink*
    BabyFruit Ticker
    Waiting to meet the baby broccoli on 5/5/2013!
  • edited April 2011
    CN:

    OP feels that there are a huge list of duties that BM sign up for when accepting the position.  The bride may choose to kick her out for a laundry list of reasons, but she should at least verbalize that she is being kicked out, because the BM will surely understand! (ETA: baaaaaad advice!!!)

    OP was a BM in a friend's wedding.  The friend told her she no longer wanted to be her friend, but didn't say anything about her role in the WP.  They made up some time later, but wasn't asked back in the WP and she was confused.  She found that her friend posted on TK about booting a BM, and someone (it had to be a newb, I could bet anything on it) patted her on the back for booting the OP.  So she blames us for giving the friend crappy advice.

    HTH!
  • OP that pretty much exactly what happened to me. She still hasnt brought up anything about the situation to me at all. the only difference is we knew during our fight that it wasnt a permanent thing
    Heather & Michael
  • I don't know what else to say other than: 1. I'm sorry you had a bad experience with your (ex)friend, 2. I know we did not advise her to kick you out of the WP, 3. I don't think your advice about kicking people out of WP is good, we're anti-kicking BMs around here, 4. and good luck with your marriage.
  • Please, PLEASE tell me this was a joke.  I'd hate to think the OP is some heinous hosebeast who really thinks it's okay to kick out a BM as long as it's done "nicely"
    image

    Stop The Drama!

    image Love people. Use things. Never confuse the two.
  • Nobody here would tell somebody it's ok to kick out a bridesmaid. As far as your advice, the only requirement of a bridesmaid is to show up in a right dress in the right place on the right day. Period. The other stuff is nice to do if the BM would like to, but certainly not required.

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_getting-rid-of-bridesmaid?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:78947719-9794-4854-82e2-692ed3a2e84cPost:fb273b0a-afc3-4f38-a940-c37b6de123f3">Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid</a>:
    [QUOTE]CN: OP feels that there are a huge list of duties that BM sign up for when accepting the position.  The bride may choose to kick her out for a laundry list of reasons, but she should at least verbalize that she is being kicked out, because the BM will surely understand! (ETA: baaaaaad advice!!!) OP was a BM in a friend's wedding.  <strong>The friend told her she no longer wanted to be her friend</strong>, but didn't say anything about her role in the WP.  They made up some time later, but wasn't asked back in the WP and she was confused.  <strong>She found that her friend posted on TK about booting a BM, and someone (it had to be a newb, I could bet anything on it) patted her on the back for booting the OP.  So she blames us for giving the friend crappy advice.</strong> HTH!
    Posted by marinabreeze[/QUOTE]


    This just reeks of the OP doing something really horrible and bitchy that she's not telling us....I'm imagining something like this:

    OP did something awful which would lead to ending the friendship (stealing, trying to sleep with the bride's FI, etc).  Bride came to TK, told us about her horrible friend who she didn't want to be friends with anymore, let alone have her stand up in her wedding, so she was told to end the friendship which therefore, as common sense would dictate, ends her role as BM.  OP lacks common sense and needs things spelled out for her that "no more being friends = no more being a BM".  So now she thinks that we give bad advice because she can't figure that out.

    Sound about right?
    Anniversary
  • I tried googling it, but this was the best I could do. 
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_getting-rid-of-bridesmaid?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:9Discussion:78947719-9794-4854-82e2-692ed3a2e84cPost:4c920697-fe58-4064-abb8-052e09d6a2c0">Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid</a>:
    [QUOTE]In Response to Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid : This just reeks of the OP doing something really horrible and bitchy that she's not telling us....I'm imagining something like this: OP did something awful which would lead to ending the friendship (stealing, trying to sleep with the bride's FI, etc).  Bride came to TK, told us about her horrible friend who she didn't want to be friends with anymore, let alone have her stand up in her wedding, so she was told to end the friendship which therefore, as common sense would dictate, ends her role as BM.  OP lacks common sense and needs things spelled out for her that "no more being friends = no more being a BM".  So now she thinks that we give bad advice because she can't figure that out. Sound about right?
    Posted by jemmini6[/QUOTE]
    I wonder this too, jemmini.  And you might be right.

    If it was a straight "can I kick out my BM" post, I can't see most of us saying that kicking her out was a terrible idea, except for the almost inevitable "captain save-a-newb" who validates her idea.  But if there was a consensus of some sort in response to the post, maybe the OP of this post did something really bad that meant that the friendship should be ended as well as her role as BM.  That's why I asked the OP of this post to include a link of the friend's thread.  I kind of doubt she will, though.
  • Nevermind.  I found thepost, but the person who OP is talking about doesn't come around to E.
  • hmm I took her "rules" as sarcasm. I think? It seems like maybe that's what her friend did to her so she is saying that's how it is supposedly done.
  • So kicking out a BM is ok as long as you're super sweet about it, explain to he that number mean more than the friendship, and explain to her that the 90 day probationary period is over and she just couldn't hack it as a BM. Did I get that right??

    Good luck with your wedding!
    image
  • Wow.  Reading that took 10 minutes of my life I can never get back....

    Anniversary
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_etiquette_getting-rid-of-bridesmaid?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:9Discussion:78947719-9794-4854-82e2-692ed3a2e84cPost:affdcdd7-15f3-431b-a0cd-291dc24e5963">Re: Getting Rid of a Bridesmaid</a>:
    [QUOTE]Uh, or you could just not be a jerkoff by kicking out your BM. That's way easier than reading the novel you just typed.<strong> Good luck! (you're welcome Annie)
    </strong>Posted by laurenclaire1386[/QUOTE]

    :)
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    282image Invited to celebrate!
    208image Will be Dancing the night away!
    74image Won't be having any fun
    0image are giving me a major headache

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards