Chit Chat

NWR: Slow cooker recommendations?

I discovered last night that the stoneware insert of my slow cooker cracked all the way through on its bottom.  Now I need a new one so that I can make the pork roast I purchased before that unhappy discovery.  So I thought I would ask you all for recommendations with your real world experience while I go through reviews for the millions of slow cookers out there.  What brand have you had good success with?  Does anyone have the one with nesting 2, 4 and 6 quart inserts?  Does anyone have one of the really large ones like you see at barbecues with 50 people?

The one that just died was a Hamilton Beach Set n' Forget Programmable 6 quart slow cooker.  I never used any of the cooking features other than the manual settings, though I guess I could with the next one.  I do have to travel with it when it is full, so the clips for the lid are pretty much a must.  

I use it most often for 2-3 pound roasts with veggies (potatoes, carrots, onion), but the 6 quart didn't hold enough so I also do a second batch of just veggies in the oven at the same time.  I also do slightly smaller batches of pulled bbq chicken or just a roast with a slow cooker sauce.  I have a smaller Hamilton Beach 2 or 4 quart slow cooker that I use when making hot dips (not sure on the actual size because my mom gave me her old one) as well.

Re: NWR: Slow cooker recommendations?

  • I just got the Hamilton Beach one for a wedding present. It's pretty much the best one I could find that I could either easily order or get to that had the digital display, clips on the lid and was a little bit bigger than our previous one (I think it was a 4 qt. Crock Pot brand from Target-that broke). The ability to have it set itself to warm when done cooking is a lifesaver.
  • I have a 4qt Rival right now that I've had for a million years. Nothing fancy, just Low, High and Warm, but it does the trick and was big enough for the two of us. Big batches of soup are a challenge though. I also have the Oster electric roaster with the 3 chafing dishes and ADORE that thing. Perfect for cooking the moistest Thanksgiving turkey you've ever seen, and then keeping the gravy and whatnot warm.

    I registered for the Crock Pot brand one with the locking clips on the sides after seriously swooning over it when my friends brought it over for our Soup Swap (like a cookie exchange but with soup).

    I think all the ones my mom has that are older than the stars are Crock Pot brand.

    image
    image
  • They don't seem to have my favorite any more but I'm sure they have something similar.  Crock pot brand. High/low settings.  Can set the time on it in 30 minute increments.  Automatic switch to warm when it's done cooking.  
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • You can actually buy replacement inserts for slow cookers.  I ordered mine off the CrockPot website. Just have to know what model you have. Way cheaper than buying a whole new unit, as long as the heating unit still works.
  • @RebeccaB88  I actually did try to find a replacement insert, but for about $20 more I can just have an entire new slow cooker.  Plus, since I have had it for so long there is no telling how much longer the heating element would last.  Might as well just get a new one now.

    @APDSS22 @kimches @mysticl I was definitely already leaning towards HB just because their stuff seems to last so long, plus they seemed to cook evenly.  I definitely need to learn how to set one to switch to warm automatically.  I know my old one was capable of that, I just didn't use it.  I decided to just get the newer model of the one I had before, and actually learn how to use all the nifty features this time.

    @lolo883  Thank you for mentioning that Oster Roaster!  I have considered getting one for a long time, and FI and I had decided to put one on our registry and then forgot about it.  I didn't realize they had ones that came with chafing dishes.  I went and found the one you mentioned and added it to our registry last night.  Now I am ridiculously excited and really hope we get it.
  • I have a 5 qt hamilton beach with locking lid. It has been a great slow cooker and I love it. Would definitely buy again. The locking lid is a feature that is a must on all crock pots I buy in the future. The drawback: no digital display.
    *********************************************************************************

    image
  • I have a HB that I bought used at a garage sale in 1999. We use it 2-3x/week in the winter but less in the summer. We just bought a huge HB at Black Friday that we use for family events and we love that as well.

    I don't use any of the fancy features, though the locking lid would be nice. I don't care about digital displays either. I do love how my HBs cook evenly and predictably.

    My sister bought the super-cute CrockPot French Bull design at Target a few months ago. It's super-cute but she doesn't think it works as well as her old HB.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards