OP, the reason for the responses you're getting is because grand gestures such as this have the potential to put a lot of pressure on those you are asking. There are a million reasons why someone may not be able to be a bridesmaid (time, money, just don't LIKE being in weddings, etc.), and these gifts can sometimes make a friend feel like they CAN'T say no (especially if they are asking in a group, hence beethery's question). Food for thought. (You are incredibly crafty though, and if you're planning on doing a lot of DIY for your wedding, I think it will be absolutely lovely based on what I've seen.)
Now, I'm personally curious as to what all is on the "roles" insert, as there seems to be a lot more on that sheet than "get a dress" and "show up"...
Knottie89170834 said:
Hi!Newly engaged and very
excited to get my girls on board, I have made the boxes of love that you may
have seen floating around Pinterest (and elsewhere, I suppose). When I was
embarking on this project I looked around a lot for inspiration, so I thought I'd
share my own project for anyone else doing the same!I started with these
boxes. They were 60% off at Michael’s-- $1.50!
I decorated the tops using ModPodge and scrapbook paper. I
made the “logo” with my Cricut machine—a scrapbooking machine that looks like a
paper but cuts out shapes, etc. Once it was all glued down, I tripped the edges
with a bit of ribbon and added some pretty white lace and flowers.
Here’s all the goodies I packed inside!
First there’s the packet of papers—information on the dresses, the roles for the girls, a list of the bridesmaids (with phone numbers), info about the color scheme and “theme”, and a collage of inspiration photos. Since it’s a winter wedding, I skipped the champagne &
fancy glasses and included hand-painted mugs, hot cocoa, and Bailey’s. As far
as the paining on glass thing—make sure you leave lots of time for the paint to
dry in between coats or your first coat will move around and make a mess. They aren't exactly masterpieces, but I have heard that it is the thought that counts.
A few other things are included: macaroons (from the lovely
French bakery in my town), a vintage handkerchief (I bought a cheap lot of them
on Ebay and washed them—they are lovely!), a nail polish in a coordinating
color, a sparkly snowflake (as opposed to a flower—yay winter weddings!), paint
swatches in my colors, and this, rolled and tied with ribbon:
Here it is:
I’m very happy with the way they turned out! I hope you like
them too!
***************
These are really cute, but the bolded paragraph is hella concerning. Have you actually asked these women to be in your wedding party yet? Have you asked them individually for their budgets, or have you just decided on a dress and are requiring them to buy that one? Also, your party doesn't have "roles." Their only job is to get the correct dress (within their budget, which you should be asking them for) and show up on the day of the wedding to stand next to you. That's it. They are not your brideslaves, no matter what Pinterest tells you.
Gah, thanks for quoting, esstee, and for bringing up the dress point--I forgot both in my post. (I was too busy forgetting how to spell every other word.)
Please don't take this as a dig, because I can tell you worked hard on this, but I would consider holding off on actually giving these to your bridesmaids. From the program picture, it looks like you're not getting married until January 2017. A lot can change in the next 2+ years. You might want to wait until your closer to your date to ask.
Also, to echo PPs, please ask your bridesmaids for their budget before you tell them what dress their buying. And their only "role" should be to show up to your wedding on time, in their bridesmaid dress. Remember these are your best friends, not free labor to help you with your wedding.
Newly engaged and very
excited to get my girls on board, I have made the boxes of love that you may
have seen floating around Pinterest (and elsewhere, I suppose). When I was
embarking on this project I looked around a lot for inspiration, so I thought I'd
share my own project for anyone else doing the same!
I started with these
boxes. They were 60% off at Michael’s-- $1.50!
I decorated the tops using ModPodge and scrapbook paper. I
made the “logo” with my Cricut machine—a scrapbooking machine that looks like a
paper but cuts out shapes, etc. Once it was all glued down, I tripped the edges
with a bit of ribbon and added some pretty white lace and flowers.
Here’s all the goodies I packed inside!
First there’s the packet of papers—information on the dresses,
the roles for the girls, a list of the bridesmaids (with phone numbers), info
about the color scheme and “theme”, and a collage of inspiration photos.
Since it’s a winter wedding, I skipped the champagne &
fancy glasses and included hand-painted mugs, hot cocoa, and Bailey’s. As far
as the paining on glass thing—make sure you leave lots of time for the paint to
dry in between coats or your first coat will move around and make a mess. They aren't exactly masterpieces, but I have heard that it is the thought that counts.
A few other things are included: macaroons (from the lovely
French bakery in my town), a vintage handkerchief (I bought a cheap lot of them
on Ebay and washed them—they are lovely!), a nail polish in a coordinating
color, a sparkly snowflake (as opposed to a flower—yay winter weddings!), paint
swatches in my colors, and this, rolled and tied with ribbon:
Here it is:
I’m very happy with the way they turned out! I hope you like
them too!
Please let this be MUD.
My vision is horrid. And enlarging these photos creates a blur that makes your "inserts" difficult to read. However, I am almost certain I can read that you have named "point persons" for your shower and bachelorette parties. It would also appear that you have requested that the other minions/BM's "follow their lead". You have also included a disclaimer statement as to how participating in a wedding is a lot of work for a BM as well as expensive.
I am almost grateful I cannot read the complete text.
OP, your wedding is not until 2017. It is WAY to early to be asking friends to be in your bridal party. You have made choices for things that directly impact your BM before knowing whether they will participate, and before speaking with them regarding their budgets.
It is not your girls that need to "get on board". I strongly encourage you to read/lurk these boards and figure out the difference between gracious bride/friend and bridezilla.
It's way too early and you seem to have huge expectations of your bridesmaids. It's extraordinarily thoughtless to lay all of this on someone.
If you do this, I expect to see you posting here over the next few years about bridesmaids that disappoint and feelings of being deserted by your friends.
Remember: your bridesmaids are your friends, not your bitches.
Again, nice job on the crafty DIY aspect, and if you were making "Good luck at college!" boxes with nifty little gifts and some good advice for your favorite college freshman I would be praising you up and down.
But if I were on the receiving end of this specific box, I would run. I would run so far away. Except not, because I would feel extremely pressured and awkward and I would likely not feel like I could be honest and just silently resent you instead.
This box is overwhelming, and NOT in an "Oh, you're so sweet to give me these things to show how much our friendship means to you" kind of way. Overwhelming in a "WTF you controlling task master? You've already picked out what I'm supposed to wear without consulting me about what style or budget I'm even comfortable with, telling me I have to spend a lot of money on you, and already giving out my phone number to people without my permission or my even agreeing to be in your wedding yet?" I would be livid about the phone number especially. I am very picky about who I give my number to and if I wasn't close enough to the other bridesmaids for them to already have my number, I sure as heck wouldn't want you giving it out. They are (potentially) bridesmaids - that doesn't mean they have to be BFFs now. If they want to get together and coordinate something and give each other their phone numbers, that is their decision to make, not yours (And yes, I have stopped talking to people for giving out my phone number without my permission.)
Please, please, please scale this back and rethink your approach.
I'd recommend asking each girl, and then give them the boxes LATER. Just in case any say no, you don't want to show her that you already printed her name on the contact list. It can be uncomfortable. I'd also skip dress info until you talked to them about budgets and concerns. The boxes are cute, and they may really love them, but just wait until they agree to give the boxes out.
Well, since I'm kind of lurking, when is a good time to ask the girls to be a bridesmaid? And if they agree to do it, can you still send them a cute gift like a wine glass and small bottle of wine? Just trying to see what's right and wrong.
Well, since I'm kind of lurking, when is a good time to ask the girls to be a bridesmaid? And if they agree to do it, can you still send them a cute gift like a wine glass and small bottle of wine? Just trying to see what's right and wrong.
It's usually best to ask them 9-10 months before the wedding. That way, they have adequate time to purchase a dress and make arrangements as necessary. Friendships can change over time, so it's best to wait a bit before asking.
I think a wine glass & bottle of wine are great gifts (assuming they enjoy wine, of course). I would suggest purchasing the gift after she has accepted. It's awkward to say no to someone when she is giving you a gift along with the question.
OP's idea includes bridesmaid "duties" and other things that are a bit presumptuous and assume that the women will say yes.
You did a lovely job on these, and it was a very nice package! Your attention to all these details shows that you are very dedicated and detail oriented, and filled with enthusiasm. Good for you!
All that having been said, please please don't give these to anyone.
This should not be a 'asking' gift. It's simply too much pressure. You already have their line up and prices and duties on there, and sorry, but that just too much pressure and expectations when you're asking someone.
This is something you should give AFTER they've said yes!
You should NOT give them to the girls until every. single. one. is confirmed.
I get it- the cute 'asking people to be your bridesmaid' thing is truly adorable on pinterest. In reality, it's better to send a 'thank you for agreeing to be my bridesmaid!' gift, if you are so inclined.The things I would remove: anything about duties and prices, any personal information about the other bridal party members. And your very thorough paperwork is more logistical stuff that should be done much closer to the wedding (like a few months ahead at most.)
You should also not give them to them for another year at least.
I agree with the other ladies, this is very early- like others said, a lot can happen in over two years- as hard as it can be to think about that. I'm lucky in that almost everyone in my bridal party is someone I've known for over a decade-but on top of that, my engagement was very short- only 7 months. If I was given 2+ yrs, I would not be planning my wedding quite yet- as so very much can change in that time- and most venues won't even take a look more than a year in advance.
I'm so sorry to say this, when you are obviously very excited, and have done an amazing job putting these together down to the last detail.
Well, since I'm kind of lurking, when is a good time to ask the girls to be a bridesmaid? And if they agree to do it, can you still send them a cute gift like a wine glass and small bottle of wine? Just trying to see what's right and wrong.
I'd ask about 10 months before. You can absolutely send a gift like that after they accept. I think a bottle of wine is perfect.
Hi everyone! Thank you so much for all of your feedback, it was really kind of you to give your thoughts. You didn't scare me, lol-- I'm just not on here daily.
I should have qualified that I've already confirmed most of this information with the girls, who have been known bridesmaids for years. Nothing in there would surprise them. I promise I'm not insane! A lot of the criticisms you all aired-- totally legitimate, I may add-- are totally heard and I will take them into consideration. Maybe I will leave out the papers and just give them the present portion after everyone officially says "yes", and perhaps I will wait a while (or a year) first. I can eat macaroons.
Sorry, I am very embarrassed! I just got a little over excited, and I tend to be a hyper-communicator who believes that being straightforward is the best way to avoid miscommunication. I guess I need to practice. I'm glad I posted and got feedback.
Apologies. I was short and sharp, and while all the above advice was sound and good, it's no excuse.
I have been known to get uber excited about things myself, and run full steam ahead without careful consideration and research. (Which is why I have a nine foot tall moon sitting in the corner of my living room.)
Hi everyone! Thank you so much for all of your feedback, it was really kind of you to give your thoughts. You didn't scare me, lol-- I'm just not on here daily.
I should have qualified that I've already confirmed most of this information with the girls, who have been known bridesmaids for years. Nothing in there would surprise them. I promise I'm not insane! A lot of the criticisms you all aired-- totally legitimate, I may add-- are totally heard and I will take them into consideration. Maybe I will leave out the papers and just give them the present portion after everyone officially says "yes", and perhaps I will wait a while (or a year) first. I can eat macaroons.
Sorry, I am very embarrassed! I just got a little over excited, and I tend to be a hyper-communicator who believes that being straightforward is the best way to avoid miscommunication. I guess I need to practice. I'm glad I posted and got feedback.
I appreciate it ladies, thank you
You handled that criticism really well. Don't be embarrassed! And stick around. Lots of good advice here ;-)
Not 100% grace-- you will notice that I have changed my "avatar" and am hiding my face (and what's more, FI's face) in embarrassment. haha! I will ditch all the printouts. Much appreciated, I've never been a bridesmaid before-- I thought I was being clear and helpful, so thank you for being honest and helping me to get my head out of my bum.
Hi everyone! Thank you so much for all of your feedback, it was really kind of you to give your thoughts. You didn't scare me, lol-- I'm just not on here daily.
I should have qualified that I've already confirmed most of this information with the girls, who have been known bridesmaids for years. Nothing in there would surprise them. I promise I'm not insane! A lot of the criticisms you all aired-- totally legitimate, I may add-- are totally heard and I will take them into consideration. Maybe I will leave out the papers and just give them the present portion after everyone officially says "yes", and perhaps I will wait a while (or a year) first. I can eat macaroons.
Sorry, I am very embarrassed! I just got a little over excited, and I tend to be a hyper-communicator who believes that being straightforward is the best way to avoid miscommunication. I guess I need to practice. I'm glad I posted and got feedback.
Re: "Will You Be My Bridesmaid?" Boxes
I'm the fuck out.
I decorated the tops using ModPodge and scrapbook paper. I made the “logo” with my Cricut machine—a scrapbooking machine that looks like a paper but cuts out shapes, etc. Once it was all glued down, I tripped the edges with a bit of ribbon and added some pretty white lace and flowers.
Here’s all the goodies I packed inside!
First there’s the packet of papers—information on the dresses, the roles for the girls, a list of the bridesmaids (with phone numbers), info about the color scheme and “theme”, and a collage of inspiration photos.
Since it’s a winter wedding, I skipped the champagne & fancy glasses and included hand-painted mugs, hot cocoa, and Bailey’s. As far as the paining on glass thing—make sure you leave lots of time for the paint to dry in between coats or your first coat will move around and make a mess. They aren't exactly masterpieces, but I have heard that it is the thought that counts.
A few other things are included: macaroons (from the lovely French bakery in my town), a vintage handkerchief (I bought a cheap lot of them on Ebay and washed them—they are lovely!), a nail polish in a coordinating color, a sparkly snowflake (as opposed to a flower—yay winter weddings!), paint swatches in my colors, and this, rolled and tied with ribbon: Here it is:
I’m very happy with the way they turned out! I hope you like them too!
***************
These are really cute, but the bolded paragraph is hella concerning. Have you actually asked these women to be in your wedding party yet? Have you asked them individually for their budgets, or have you just decided on a dress and are requiring them to buy that one? Also, your party doesn't have "roles." Their only job is to get the correct dress (within their budget, which you should be asking them for) and show up on the day of the wedding to stand next to you. That's it. They are not your brideslaves, no matter what Pinterest tells you.
My vision is horrid. And enlarging these photos creates a blur that makes your "inserts" difficult to read. However, I am almost certain I can read that you have named "point persons" for your shower and bachelorette parties. It would also appear that you have requested that the other minions/BM's "follow their lead". You have also included a disclaimer statement as to how participating in a wedding is a lot of work for a BM as well as expensive.
I am almost grateful I cannot read the complete text.
OP, your wedding is not until 2017. It is WAY to early to be asking friends to be in your bridal party. You have made choices for things that directly impact your BM before knowing whether they will participate, and before speaking with them regarding their budgets.
It is not your girls that need to "get on board". I strongly encourage you to read/lurk these boards and figure out the difference between gracious bride/friend and bridezilla.
Good job on the DIY, but as others have said, you are putting them in an incredibly uncomfortable situation. And you are asking way way way too early.
It's way too early and you seem to have huge expectations of your bridesmaids. It's extraordinarily thoughtless to lay all of this on someone.
If you do this, I expect to see you posting here over the next few years about bridesmaids that disappoint and feelings of being deserted by your friends.
Remember: your bridesmaids are your friends, not your bitches.
But if I were on the receiving end of this specific box, I would run. I would run so far away. Except not, because I would feel extremely pressured and awkward and I would likely not feel like I could be honest and just silently resent you instead.
This box is overwhelming, and NOT in an "Oh, you're so sweet to give me these things to show how much our friendship means to you" kind of way. Overwhelming in a "WTF you controlling task master? You've already picked out what I'm supposed to wear without consulting me about what style or budget I'm even comfortable with, telling me I have to spend a lot of money on you, and already giving out my phone number to people without my permission or my even agreeing to be in your wedding yet?" I would be livid about the phone number especially. I am very picky about who I give my number to and if I wasn't close enough to the other bridesmaids for them to already have my number, I sure as heck wouldn't want you giving it out. They are (potentially) bridesmaids - that doesn't mean they have to be BFFs now. If they want to get together and coordinate something and give each other their phone numbers, that is their decision to make, not yours (And yes, I have stopped talking to people for giving out my phone number without my permission.)
Please, please, please scale this back and rethink your approach.
Well, since I'm kind of lurking, when is a good time to ask the girls to be a bridesmaid? And if they agree to do it, can you still send them a cute gift like a wine glass and small bottle of wine? Just trying to see what's right and wrong.
It's usually best to ask them 9-10 months before the wedding. That way, they have adequate time to purchase a dress and make arrangements as necessary. Friendships can change over time, so it's best to wait a bit before asking.
I'm the fuck out.