Hey! This one is sort of a weird situation and I could use some advice...
Because of some issues with packages being stolen at our old apartment I signed up for UPS MyChoice, which sends me an email whenever there is a package scheduled to be delivered the next day, that way I knew when to expect something and when I should know to react if there was nothing there. In the meantime, FI (now DH of 3 weeks) and I moved across the country and I didn't bother updating UPS MyChoice because our mail delivery is secure. At the same time, we'd just gotten engaged back then and were playing around with what we wanted to set up for a registry. I had hastily added a couple of things I kind of liked to a list of West Elm but never linked it to our wedding website (or the knot's registry page since that's the first thing that shows up in google when you search my or DH's names).
I just got an email from UPS MyChoice this morning letting me know there is a delivery scheduled for tomorrow at my Seattle address, meanwhile I've lived in NY since April now. I look it up and see it's being shipped from Williams-Sonoma (so, West Elm), so I log into West Elm and lo and behold 2 items were purchased by the wife of one of DH's friends (they weren't able to make the wedding). I looked into trying to have the package rerouted, but it's being sent in 2 different shipments and UPS wants to charge me $36 for each package to be sent to my current address (and $36 is more than the total value of the gifts themselves.)
What do I do? Should we reach out and let them know "hey, we don't live in Seattle anymore?" My mind is boggled as to how she even found the West Elm registry in the first place as it hasn't been shared anywhere and I can't find it when searching Google for search terms that make sense. Our wedding website has our registry on it and if search either of our names with terms like "registry" or "wedding" theknot's registry page with the link to our correct registries is what comes up. I don't want it to be awkward, but I also don't want to spent $72 of my own money rerouting gifts valued at $38. I wouldn't even know about this if I didn't have UPS MyChoice. Help!