My family is driving me crazy about my BM's attire. I wanted them all to be comfortable, so I let them choose different dresses in the same color. They ended up coordinating together anyway, and all except the MOH are going to be in the same material/length, just different styles. My mom has finally come to terms with this, but she just doesn't understand why I would not pick just one dress and can't fathom different dresses looking good. Even after I've shown her pictures.
Now, we're on shoes. I really don't care what will be on their feet, I probably won't even notice. They all wanted a little direction, so I just said anything in gray/silver. Again, mom thinks this will not look good. My aunt and I were arguing about this and I said to her: "No one goes to the wedding to look at the BM's shoes." and she actually said back, "I do!" Like, wow. I can't.
I try to talk about this stuff as limited as possible with family, and I now change the subject immediately when it is brought up. I know that is all I can do, I just thought I'd share/vent with you guys!
Re: I just don't understand... (VENT)
Yeah, I had people like that too. EVERYONE was going crazy about wanting everyone to match perfectly, and I really didn't care at all. My MIL even freaked out because all the groomsmen were wearing 2-button navy blue suits and she could only find 3-button in my nephews size! In their defense, they were just concerned about wanting everything to be perfect for me. I understand that, but do they think I was lying when I said things looked ok or I don't care what color their shoes are? I just repeatedly told them that it really doesn't matter to me if everything matches perfectly and when they showed me an option, I'd say it looks fine.
In my experience, there really wasn't any way to calm them down on that one. Unfortunately, you probably just need to suffer through it.
A litle advice from a 4 time MOB here.....
This is a generation thing you are dealing with. Back in the day or our weddings/our mothers weddings the marriages would have been invalid and our children illegitimate if everything didn't match exactly and the BM's didn't look like clones. I am guessing Armageddon would have occured if we would have had uneven sides in our bridal parties.
I have been on forums for years and see the newer trends, LOVE the newer trends (so wish my generation would have been the one to say we were going to do it differently!). Your moms? Not so much. They know what they now.
Google some spectacular wedding pics and show them how this really is done now and it is very common. It may take some time, but seeing can lead to believing. I remember when my first DD got engaged ten years ago and I heard about a "first look". What the Hell? Who would do that? That is the dumbest idea I had ever heard. Now....I am a huge proponent of it (and she did go for a first look BTW) and 3 of my 4 girls chose to do them.
Start googling and chat with mom when she is in a good mood. Grandma may not sway so easily, but you gotta show them how it is done now. Good luck to you all!