DIY Wedding Forum

DIY Ice cream sundae bar... ideas?

My fiance and I are hoping to have an ice cream sundae for dessert instead of cake for our May 2022 wedding!
Has anyone put on an ice cream sundae bar on their own and how did you do it?

Re: DIY Ice cream sundae bar... ideas?

  • My fiance and I are hoping to have an ice cream sundae for dessert instead of cake for our May 2022 wedding!
    Has anyone put on an ice cream sundae bar on their own and how did you do it?
    My sister did this for her rehearsal dinner and it was A LOT harder than we thought it would be. It was messy, took up a ton of space, & ultimately I think more work than it was worth. We didn’t even have that many people and it was kind of a disaster. 

    That said if you’re trying to do it definitely have someone responsible for scooping/ doing the ice cream part. If you have a big freezer scoop the ice cream a head of time and store it. Have a ton of space for toppings. Way more space than you think you need. I would limit the ice cream flavors to only 1-2 because it’s going to take someone a while to scoop them. 
  • Thank you so much for that perspective!!
  • climbingsingleclimbingsingle NYC 'burbs member
    10000 Comments Seventh Anniversary 500 Love Its 5 Answers
    The times I've seen this at a wedding, it ended up being very messy. Also, experiencing Covid has really made me change how I feel about things like this, and it doesn't sound appealing. As clean as people can be, you've still got multiple hands reaching into ice cream, toppings, etc. It's not appealing IMO. 

  • This what I indicated when I responded on the other thread. 

    I think you'll have to have others doing the scooping but consider what it is to wait in line for ice cream at any store.  Now imagine you're in a group of 100 people.   Just think about the timing involved.  There's no way that will work as the only dessert without some grumpy people or those who just opt to go without and you HAVE to make this only DIY in that you buy the toppings in advance but always have trained people to make the sundaes.
  • Pre-Covid, we did an ice cream sundae bar for a funeral (yes, a funeral, because the guy loved ice cream and his widow wanted this) at our church. We had about 200 people. We did 4 stations, all with the same ice creams and toppings. We served them. No one was allowed to touch anything except their own bowl and spoon.

    It takes a while to soften giant tubs of ice cream, so consider using coolers of smaller tubs at each station. Definitely have only 2 flavors of ice cream, plus a small amount of sorbet at each station. People are indecisive and the more choices you have, the slower the line. We needed 2 servers per station, one for ice cream, one for toppings. And yes, it was a royal mess, so make sure the servers have aprons and several changes of gloves.

    I like your idea, but think long and hard about this. Buffet things are kind of ick in a post-Covid world. I would personally be a bit squeamish unless things looked super hygienic.
  • MesmrEweMesmrEwe member
    Knottie Warrior 2500 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers
    We had both cake and ice cream...  We did the Ice Cream Cups (you know the things with the wooden stick "spoon" type so serving them was as easy as walking around with a wheeled cooler because as others said messy and takes forever to serve if you do it the regular way.  The one way it could work is if you've got something like many places in Wisconsin which is a "Dairy Barn" setup where 4 people can be serving on two sides and the icecream kept at proper temperatures for scooping and serving.  Either way it's still messy as heck.  I've also seen where people give everyone a ticket and they have an icecream truck come in and serve everyone a treat.  

    The one thing no one else has touched on but should be noted, a lot of people are sensitive to dairy and nuts so that's something to strongly consider in your options available.  
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • LiksyLiksy Denver newb
    First Comment
    It is important to do it the way you want. But if you're not sure if you want to mess with ice cream, you better not. You will spend a lot of effort and resources, and still the result will not be good enough.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards