So I finally heard from the first property manager, yesterday. They didn't have the townhouse I'd applied for, so I could go to a nicer model (+$100/mo), or go to an equivalent one in another complex. The major issue with the other complex was that it is in B.F.nowhere, with the nearest grocery store and post office over a 15 minute drive away. Thanks, but no thanks.
I heard back from the other property manager today though. They accepted my application, my credit went through, and I'm going to be signing a lease on Friday! Woo. It's an apartment, instead of a townhouse, but the complex is brand new and I'll be the first to live in this unit. Also, it has a garage, which is a HUGE deal to me after the snowmageddon this past winter.
Just thought I'd fill you all in. Thanks for the advice from those who gave it. It made walking away from the other company a lot easier.