this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Etiquette Forum

Throwing a Bridal Shower?

Let me see if I have this correct, a bride cannot throw her own bridal shower, nor can she ask someone else to throw it for her? Am I the only bride out there that thinks these "rules" are total crap? I keep hearing "a bridal shower is not a right" and "if no-one offers then you just go without". Maybe I'm a narcissist, but I want one! And I do feel entitled to one! Why would it be so bad for me to throw my own? Because I'll look "gift-grabby"? How is it any different than having a wedding? You pay for a party and some people bring gifts. (It's also the same as throwing a birthday party for yourself.) I understand that there is etiquette, but is it really THAT bad if I throw my own shower? And really, I'm not concerned about gifts - I just want to play the ridiculous party games with my fiancé (Jack and Jill Wedding Shower) and drink mimosas.
«13

Re: Throwing a Bridal Shower?

  • Do you really not care that people will talk shit about you since you're being so rude?
  • Have a get together at your house with mimosas. Play the games if you insist. But don't call it a shower, or really anything wedding-related.
  • edited March 2014
    Personally, i think the hosting your shower and hosting your own wedding are the same thing.  Etiquette is only okay with hosting your own wedding because they know most couples pay for their own weddings, nowadays. If etiquette weren't okay with hosting your own wedding reception, very few people would have large scale weddings. I am not hosting my own shower, but I still find this double standard a  little ridiculous. But with all things related to etiquette, you have to follow them, whether you agree with them, or not.  You don't want other people being horribly offended, even though you're not.
  • MGPMGP member
    Knottie Warrior 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    It's time for a Shower Planning 101 sticky.  I would be happy to draft one up.

  • Personally, i think the hosting your shower and hosting your own wedding are the same thing.  Etiquette is only okay with hosting your own wedding because they know most couples pay for their own weddings, nowadays. If etiquette weren't okay with hosting your own wedding reception, very few people would have large scale weddings. I am not hosting my own shower, but I still find this double standard a  little ridiculous. But with all things related to etiquette, you have to follow them, whether you agree with them, or not.  You don't want other people being horribly offended, even though you're not.
    In no way is this the same.  A shower is a literal gift giving event; you "shower" the bride with gifts. A wedding reception is in fact the opposite; you're throwing a party for your guests to thank them for witnessing you and your SO exchange vows and taking each others hands in marriage. As well, it is not in bad etiquette to not give a gift at a wedding.

    This has nothing to do with the B&G paying for their own wedding.


    imageimage



  • Are you the #BridalRights lady back for more?
  • edited March 2014
    I've always planned my own birthday party, if I didn't I would never have one. I think it's entirely rude to ask someone to spend their money to throw a party for you. And, actually, a "shower" is VERY similar to a wedding: it's a party to celebrate a marriage (as is a reception) in which the guests are provided with food, drinks and a fun time (as in a reception). Why does it matter who pays for it? And additionally, who is even going to know who paid for it? It's not like guests go walking around a party asking who funded it.
  • Are you the #BridalRights lady back for more?
    I have no idea who the #bridal rights lady is.
  • Personally, i think the hosting your shower and hosting your own wedding are the same thing.  Etiquette is only okay with hosting your own wedding because they know most couples pay for their own weddings, nowadays. If etiquette weren't okay with hosting your own wedding reception, very few people would have large scale weddings. I am not hosting my own shower, but I still find this double standard a  little ridiculous. But with all things related to etiquette, you have to follow them, whether you agree with them, or not.  You don't want other people being horribly offended, even though you're not.
    I'm really glad I'm not the only person who thinks it's the same thing. I really can't understand why everyone is always in an uproar over it.
  • I've always planned my own birthday party, if I didn't I would never have one. I think it's entirely rude to ask someone to spend their money to throw a party for you.
    And, actually, a "shower" is VERY similar to a wedding: it's a party to celebrate a marriage (as is a reception) in which the guests are provided with food, drinks and a fun time (as in a reception).
    Why does it matter who pays for it? And additionally, who is even going to know who paid for it? It's not like guests go walking around a party asking who funded it.

    Always planned your own birthday party? Always? As in you hired your own clown and everything?
    image
  • I've always planned my own birthday party, if I didn't I would never have one. I think it's entirely rude to ask someone to spend their money to throw a party for you. And, actually, a "shower" is VERY similar to a wedding: it's a party to celebrate a marriage (as is a reception) in which the guests are provided with food, drinks and a fun time (as in a reception). Why does it matter who pays for it? And additionally, who is even going to know who paid for it? It's not like guests go walking around a party asking who funded it.
    Always planned your own birthday party? Always? As in you hired your own clown and everything?
    Always as in, every year since my 16th birthday.
  • There is no rule that says a shower is "necessary" or "required" when you are a bride. I suppose a big reception after your wedding isn't "necessary" either, but it is gracious to offer this to your guests. It is not, however, gracious to offer a party for yourself in which guests are expected to bring gifts for you.  This is a special event that someone has to want to plan and throw for you.
  • Have a get together at your house with mimosas. Play the games if you insist. But don't call it a shower, or really anything wedding-related.
    There is no possible way that I could throw a party at this point in my engagement, no matter how I word the invitations, that people aren't going to assume I it's a wedding shower. The only other parties I ever throw are birthday parties, people will inevitably assume any party is a wedding shower.
  • I've always planned my own birthday party, if I didn't I would never have one. I think it's entirely rude to ask someone to spend their money to throw a party for you.
    And, actually, a "shower" is VERY similar to a wedding: it's a party to celebrate a marriage (as is a reception) in which the guests are provided with food, drinks and a fun time (as in a reception).
    Why does it matter who pays for it? And additionally, who is even going to know who paid for it? It's not like guests go walking around a party asking who funded it.

    Always planned your own birthday party? Always? As in you hired your own clown and everything?
    Always as in, every year since my 16th birthday.
    Did it ever occur to you that there might be a reason no one has ever wanted to throw you a birthday party since you were 16?

    I am not trying to be mean at all, but I'm wondering if perhaps you have difficulties picking up on certain social cues?
    Most people's parents stop throwing them birthday parties after a certain age.

    The only other explanation is that you have truly severe entitlement issues? If that's the case, then it's not too late to learn that no one is entitled to a party, regardless of the reason, be it an impending marriage, birthday, new job, etc.

    If no one offers to throw you a party, you should probably take the hint that no one wants to throw you a party. The next step is to ask yourself, "why?"
    image
  • I've always planned my own birthday party, if I didn't I would never have one. I think it's entirely rude to ask someone to spend their money to throw a party for you. And, actually, a "shower" is VERY similar to a wedding: it's a party to celebrate a marriage (as is a reception) in which the guests are provided with food, drinks and a fun time (as in a reception). Why does it matter who pays for it? And additionally, who is even going to know who paid for it? It's not like guests go walking around a party asking who funded it.
    Always planned your own birthday party? Always? As in you hired your own clown and everything?
    Always as in, every year since my 16th birthday.
    Did it ever occur to you that there might be a reason no one has ever wanted to throw you a birthday party since you were 16? I am not trying to be mean at all, but I'm wondering if perhaps you have difficulties picking up on certain social cues? Most people's parents stop throwing them birthday parties after a certain age. The only other explanation is that you have truly severe entitlement issues? If that's the case, then it's not too late to learn that no one is entitled to a party, regardless of the reason, be it an impending marriage, birthday, new job, etc. If no one offers to throw you a party, you should probably take the hint that no one wants to throw you a party. The next step is to ask yourself, "why?"
    This. After reading the original post, I actually felt a little sad that nobody had offered to throw a shower. But then after reading some of the other posts it made more sense. I don't know what your relationships with your bridal party or family are like, but I can tell you this: if they are such that nobody has offered to throw you a shower, throwing one for yourself will not make those relationships stronger. It absolutely will make you look entitled and egocentric.

    I understand wanting to have a shower and being disappointed if nobody throws one for you. But throwing one for yourself, I promise, isn't going to result in anything but people thinking rude things about you. 
  • dannymaymorris said:

    There is no possible way that I could throw a party at this point in my engagement, no matter how I word the invitations, that people aren't going to assume I it's a wedding shower. The only other parties I ever throw are birthday parties, people will inevitably assume any party is a wedding shower.
    What other people choose to assume,  is their problem. If you invite them to a cocktail party and they choose to bring gifts, then you receive the gifts graciously and discretely, set them quickly aside out of sight, and get on with drinks and games. If they ask you ahead of time "is this a shower" you deny it, and if they say "I'll need to get a gift -- where are you registered" you say "oh, this isn't a shower; gifts are not expected. Just come and have fun!"

    But there is another little concern with your post that I'd like to invite you to think about. You say "The only other parties I ever throw are birthday parties." Why is that? Hospitality is about bringing people together at your own expense and effort, to socialize and build community. I know that a lot of girls grow up nowadays without seeing the give-and-take of social entertaining being role-modelled for them: but society is a sadder place for that fact. And as you can now see, it comes back to bite you! If you threw those birthday parties for your friends instead of for yourself; if you gave cocktail parties or teas "just because" on occasion, then people would NOT automatically assume an ulterior motive to your entertaining. And, from watching your generosity, your friends might even get the idea to give a party for you! You have the power to make choices that will build up your community into a more generous and more gracious place.

    I may rarely agree what you post but all of your replies on here have been freakin awesome and spot on. Now if only OP would listen.....

    After 6 years and 2 boys, finally tying the knot on October 27th, 2013!

  • I don't need a special occasion to drink mimosas. And no, don't throw your own shower.
  • WeeshWeesh member
    250 Love Its Third Anniversary 100 Comments Name Dropper
    edited March 2014
    dannymaymorris said: "Let me see if I have this correct, a bride cannot throw her own bridal shower, nor can she ask someone else to throw it for her? Am I the only bride out there that thinks these "rules" are total crap? I keep hearing "a bridal shower is not a right" and "if no-one offers then you just go without". Maybe I'm a narcissist, but I want one! And I do feel entitled to one! Why would it be so bad for me to throw my own? Because I'll look "gift-grabby"? How is it any different than having a wedding? You pay for a party and some people bring gifts. (It's also the same as throwing a birthday party for yourself.) I understand that there is etiquette, but is it really THAT bad if I throw my own shower? And really, I'm not concerned about gifts - I just want to play the ridiculous party games with my fiancé (Jack and Jill Wedding Shower) and drink mimosas."
    *************************



    There's nothing wrong with wanting one.  There's something wrong with
    asking for one, expecting one, or throwing one for yourself.  The event is supposed to shower a bride with well wishes before a wedding.  Throwing your own screams "gimme."  And if you think you're "entitled" to one, there might be a reason why someone hasn't offered to throw one for you.  Getting married doesn't entitle you to anything.

    My fiance and I are paying for most of our wedding, and we don't view it as paying for a party for people to bring gifts.  I don't care if they bring anything, everyone who was invited was invited because we can't imagine getting married without them being there.  If you're not concerned about gifts, get everyone together for an evening.  Call it a barbecue, have a luncheon, go out to a bar with your bridal party, whatever.  But don't call it a shower.  

    Edited because quotes aren't working.  Ugh.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I've always planned my own birthday party, if I didn't I would never have one. I think it's entirely rude to ask someone to spend their money to throw a party for you. And, actually, a "shower" is VERY similar to a wedding: it's a party to celebrate a marriage (as is a reception) in which the guests are provided with food, drinks and a fun time (as in a reception). Why does it matter who pays for it? And additionally, who is even going to know who paid for it? It's not like guests go walking around a party asking who funded it.
    Always planned your own birthday party? Always? As in you hired your own clown and everything?
    Always as in, every year since my 16th birthday.
    Did it ever occur to you that there might be a reason no one has ever wanted to throw you a birthday party since you were 16? I am not trying to be mean at all, but I'm wondering if perhaps you have difficulties picking up on certain social cues? Most people's parents stop throwing them birthday parties after a certain age. The only other explanation is that you have truly severe entitlement issues? If that's the case, then it's not too late to learn that no one is entitled to a party, regardless of the reason, be it an impending marriage, birthday, new job, etc. If no one offers to throw you a party, you should probably take the hint that no one wants to throw you a party. The next step is to ask yourself, "why?"
    Wow, your kind of a dick, aren't you?
  • edited March 2014
    All of you people are incredibly judgmental! You should be ashamed of yourselves. My MOH can't throw my shower because she lives very far away along with one of my bridesmaids - my remaining bridesmaids I would never expect to do it because one is my 15 yr old sister and the other is a friend with three kids (she has more important things to do with her money). I would NEVER want someone to throw a party for me, I don't understand why it's okay for someone to spend money to throw me a party but it's not okay for me to throw a party in which people may or may not bring gifts. Additionally I come from a family that doesn't traditionally give gifts for any occasion - even if I had a wedding shower it would be very unlikely that I would be "showered with gifts" - we are the type of people who "shower" each other with our presence and support. I plan my own birthday parties because I enjoy being around family and friends on my birthday - and I can't possibly understand how providing food and drink for others on MY birthday could ever be considered as feeling I am entitled. And assuming that I only throw my own birthday parties is ridiculous. I throw my mother's birthday party every year, along with my nephew's. I have thrown parties for my friends as well. Saying that I wouldn't have a party if I didn't plan it myself speaks to the fact that most of the people who would throw me a party simply could not afford it, and I would never expect them to pay for something like that. I would like to add, that I never said no-one offered to throw me a shower. My grandmother and my older sister offered, neither of which have the financial means and I know it would put them in a tight place and I simply refuse to put them in that situation - I declined their offers only to be sharply criticized later when I said I would put it on myself. (Obviously, I had no idea of the "etiquette" surrounding bridal showers.) I would also like to add that I recently attended a bridal shower - I was under every impression that the bride was throwing and funding it herself. At no point in time did I consider her "gift-grabby" or "entitled" - I was simply happy to be there for her and spend time with her. Some guests brought gifts and some did not - I don't feel that anyone felt obligated and I never got the impression that she expected gifts either.
  • Ditto Lisa. Get together and have a NON GIFT GIVING party with your NON GIFT GIVING family and hang out and drink and play games like any other get-together. Just don't call it a shower. This is really not that complicated. 


    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards