Chit Chat

Ferguson

1567810

Re: Ferguson

  • I literally have to go cry.
    Overly dramatic much?
    People can't even post about Christmas songs they like without it devolving into an argument about the analysis of the freaking lyrics and outrage, and everyone being offended. . . . who the fuck thought this post was going to be a good idea and who the fuck thought participating in this thread was an equally good idea?

    Nopenopenopenopenope.
    I started it..  And maybe I'm naive, but I thought it was / is a good discussion.  I know I learned from it. 

    I'd like to think that we can take a few minutes out of discussing bridesmaid dresses and B-lists to talk about something that has a deeper impact.
    That would be great if the discussions didn't devolve into personal attacks and immaturity. . . which in my experience these very contentious topics always end up going that route when discussed via social media.

    My FB timeline is living proof of it.  It's sad, but it's why I don't touch shit like this online.

    "Love is the one thing we're capable of perceiving that transcends time and space."


  • Shit I know very few people IRL that can have a mature discussion on this topic!

    "Love is the one thing we're capable of perceiving that transcends time and space."


  • From where I started to to take part in this conversation- I've seen zero arguments, just thoughtful debate. Just a bunch of ladies politely discussing what happened and sharing their views, with a few emotionally charged moments. I get that politics and debate isn't for everyone, but you don't have to take part in the thread if it isn't your cup of tea. 
    image
  • FWIW, I started this because I know this is a very diverse group of women with views that mostly differ from my own.  I didn't want to stay in my sheltered bubble on this one - I wanted to hear what other people think.  
  • edited November 2014

    SBmini said:
    From where I started to to take part in this conversation- I've seen zero arguments, just thoughtful debate. Just a bunch of ladies politely discussing what happened and sharing their views, with a few emotionally charged moments. I get that politics and debate isn't for everyone, but you don't have to take part in the thread if it isn't your cup of tea. 
    Yep, and I'm not.

    I must have seen only the emotionally charged shit when I stopped into the thread.

    ETA: I love having these types of discussions, but not on social media.

    "Love is the one thing we're capable of perceiving that transcends time and space."


  • lilacck28lilacck28 member
    First Anniversary First Comment 5 Love Its First Answer
    edited November 2014
    Most people on my facebook wall are saying and thinking the same things I would. I do occassionally see comments/ arguments made on walls of  friends of friends that really sadden/ sicken me. Part of me thinks, man, I have an awesome circle. I keep good company. But then the other part of me thinks, I don't have to argue with anyone... maybe my brain is atrophying and Maybe I need a more politically diverse group of friends (i.e. get some conservative buddies)...
    FiancB said:
    Whenever something like this comes up, I end up being really shocked at how dumb a lot of people in my circle are. Damn. Not referring to TK but facebook and stuff. 

  • FiancB said:
    Whenever something like this comes up, I end up being really shocked at how dumb a lot of people in my circle are. Damn. Not referring to TK but facebook and stuff. 
    This. I have unfriended SO MANY people in the past 48 hours.
  • FiancB said:
    Whenever something like this comes up, I end up being really shocked at how dumb a lot of people in my circle are. Damn. Not referring to TK but facebook and stuff. 
    This. I have unfriended SO MANY people in the past 48 hours.
    Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.
  • I also have the very unpopular opinion in this case. I won't go into it.

     

    I agree with @sarahufl--the fact that Michael Brown lost his life that day is tragic. Loss of life is always a tragedy IMO.

     

    I grew up in a community where I, a white person, was the minority and have been on the opposite end of racism. It is a terrible feeling and I hate racism across the board.

     

    My family is a family of law enforcement. DH is in law enforcement. The outpouring of "cop hate" has been making me really sick to my stomach over the last several months. I can't even go onto my facebook this morning because it is just flooded. I think people have the right to be angry. I do not think people have the right to loot and hurt their community. All this hate (across all spectrums) really gets to me and hurts my heart.

     

    Ok, that is all I am going to say about this.

    You have never, ever, ever, ever, been on the opposite end of racism. You may have been on the end of prejudiced and judgement, but racism exists within a power structure.  If you are white, you own the power structure. There is no such thing as reverse racism. It does not exist.

    Do not tell me what I have and have not experienced. You have no idea and it is inappropriate. That would be like you telling me what you have experienced FROM YOUR PERSPECTIVE and then me telling you that you have never, ever *insert unnecessary use of "ever" to prove a point* experienced it.

     

    ETA:

    Here is the definition of racism:

    rac·ism
    ˈrāˌsizəm/
    noun
    noun: racism
    1. the belief that all members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, especially so as to distinguish it as inferior or superior to another race or races.
      • prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one's own race is superior.
        "a program to combat racism"
        synonyms:racial discrimination, racialism, racial prejudice, xenophobia, chauvinism, bigotry, casteism
        "Aborigines are the main victims of racism in Australia"


     

    This isn't an issue from my perspective. It's fact.   Racism in the UNITED STATES (and most other countries) is perpetrated against people of color.  White people have the power.  People of color don't.  Racism is the perpetuation of power and domination.  Living in a mostly black community as a white person did not cause you to not be able to get a job, or housing, or get profiled by police, or having a child that you knew might end up dead at the hands of police.  Having white privilege means being able to walk away from "racism" whenever you feel like it.  

    Being in a black community, you may have stood out like a sore thumb, and maybe people didn't like you, but you were not systematically oppressed.  You can claim reverse racism all you want, it doesn't make it true. 
    ^^^ This!

    Live fast, die young. Bad Girls do it well. Suki Zuki.

  • SBmini said:


    QueerFemme said:Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.

    You would lose friends over a difference of opinion like this? 
    ----------
    I have. Not for Ferguson, but for another friend who made racist comments and did not apologize.
  • QueerFemme said:Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.
    You would lose friends over a difference of opinion like this? 
    ---------- I have. Not for Ferguson, but for another friend who made racist comments and did not apologize.
    I have noticed many people on my facebook and on twitter call Michael Brown an N and how N that "are thugs deserved to be gunned down by a cop doing his job. People need to quite allowing these N be in with those who are civilized because they are going to fall by bullets..." <-- That is one of the statuses. The rest are filled with comments about how many "gorilla Ns need to stop pulling the race card." Many of the people who are commenting are family friends and some are high professionals. I haven't blocked and unfriend a person faster before in my life.

    Live fast, die young. Bad Girls do it well. Suki Zuki.

  • edited June 2015
  • SBmini said:
    QueerFemme said:Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.
    You would lose friends over a difference of opinion like this? 
    ---------- I have. Not for Ferguson, but for another friend who made racist comments and did not apologize.
    It depends on what they are doing. If they are saying ignorant, racists things that's one thing. But if they simply think that the Grand Jury was right, then I think that a blocking people out for having a different opinion closes your world to other viewpoints. You create an echo chamber. And echo chambers lead to ignorance. 
    I completely agree with this. Deleting friends who are racist is one thing, but getting rid of friends because they don't just smile and nod along with your opinion is a very different thing. I would not want a group of friends who all thinks the same way.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • AlexisA01 said:

    I also have the very unpopular opinion in this case. I won't go into it.

     

    I agree with @sarahufl--the fact that Michael Brown lost his life that day is tragic. Loss of life is always a tragedy IMO.

     

    I grew up in a community where I, a white person, was the minority and have been on the opposite end of racism. It is a terrible feeling and I hate racism across the board.

     

    My family is a family of law enforcement. DH is in law enforcement. The outpouring of "cop hate" has been making me really sick to my stomach over the last several months. I can't even go onto my facebook this morning because it is just flooded. I think people have the right to be angry. I do not think people have the right to loot and hurt their community. All this hate (across all spectrums) really gets to me and hurts my heart.

     

    Ok, that is all I am going to say about this.

    You have never, ever, ever, ever, been on the opposite end of racism. You may have been on the end of prejudiced and judgement, but racism exists within a power structure.  If you are white, you own the power structure. There is no such thing as reverse racism. It does not exist.

    Do not tell me what I have and have not experienced. You have no idea and it is inappropriate. That would be like you telling me what you have experienced FROM YOUR PERSPECTIVE and then me telling you that you have never, ever *insert unnecessary use of "ever" to prove a point* experienced it.

     

    ETA:

    Here is the definition of racism:

    rac·ism
    ˈrāˌsizəm/
    noun
    noun: racism
    1. the belief that all members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, especially so as to distinguish it as inferior or superior to another race or races.
      • prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one's own race is superior.
        "a program to combat racism"
        synonyms:racial discrimination, racialism, racial prejudice, xenophobia, chauvinism, bigotry, casteism
        "Aborigines are the main victims of racism in Australia"


     

    This isn't an issue from my perspective. It's fact.   Racism in the UNITED STATES (and most other countries) is perpetrated against people of color.  White people have the power.  People of color don't.  Racism is the perpetuation of power and domination.  Living in a mostly black community as a white person did not cause you to not be able to get a job, or housing, or get profiled by police, or having a child that you knew might end up dead at the hands of police.  Having white privilege means being able to walk away from "racism" whenever you feel like it.  

    Being in a black community, you may have stood out like a sore thumb, and maybe people didn't like you, but you were not systematically oppressed.  You can claim reverse racism all you want, it doesn't make it true. 
    ^^^ This!

    No. Not this. I still think that saying only white people can be racist is a racist comment. I am not going to back down from this opinion.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • edited November 2014
    SBmini said:
    QueerFemme said:Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.
    You would lose friends over a difference of opinion like this? 
    ---------- I have. Not for Ferguson, but for another friend who made racist comments and did not apologize.
    It depends on what they are doing. If they are saying ignorant, racists things that's one thing. But if they simply think that the Grand Jury was right, then I think that a blocking people out for having a different opinion closes your world to other viewpoints. You create an echo chamber. And echo chambers lead to ignorance. 
    I had a friend go on a rant on 9/11 claiming that Islam is a cancer that must be destroyed. I tried to rationalize with her and it did no good. I was so disgusted that I could not continue to associate with her.
  • SBmini said:
    QueerFemme said:Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.
    You would lose friends over a difference of opinion like this? 
    ---------- I have. Not for Ferguson, but for another friend who made racist comments and did not apologize.
    It depends on what they are doing. If they are saying ignorant, racists things that's one thing. But if they simply think that the Grand Jury was right, then I think that a blocking people out for having a different opinion closes your world to other viewpoints. You create an echo chamber. And echo chambers lead to ignorance. 
    ---- I had a friend go on a rant on 9/11 claiming that Islam is a cancer that must be destroyed. I tried to rationalize with her and it did no good. I was so disgusted that I could not continue to associate with her.

    Again this is something different than just getting rid of people because they don't share your opinion. I 10000000000% agree that you should have ended that friendship because what she was saying was horrible.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • abbyj700 said:
    FiancB said:
    Whenever something like this comes up, I end up being really shocked at how dumb a lot of people in my circle are. Damn. Not referring to TK but facebook and stuff. 

    SBmini said:
    QueerFemme said:Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.
    You would lose friends over a difference of opinion like this? 
    You're truly friends with all of the people on your facebook?

    I've  unfriended clearly racist and bigoted people on my facebook page all week. Mostly acquaintances that I throw darts with or small minded idiots I went to high school with. Unfriending some racist I haven't seen in 10 years isn't "losing a friend".  
    Exactly. Racism isn't a "difference of opinion".
  • abbyj700 said:
    FiancB said:
    Whenever something like this comes up, I end up being really shocked at how dumb a lot of people in my circle are. Damn. Not referring to TK but facebook and stuff. 

    SBmini said:
    QueerFemme said:Me too.   I put a blanket statement out on my facebook that if ANYONE on my FB even remotely agrees with the decision not to indict, they should just delete their asses offa my page.  My patience is gone.
    You would lose friends over a difference of opinion like this? 
    You're truly friends with all of the people on your facebook?

    I've  unfriended clearly racist and bigoted people on my facebook page all week. Mostly acquaintances that I throw darts with or small minded idiots I went to high school with. Unfriending some racist I haven't seen in 10 years isn't "losing a friend".  
    Exactly. Racism isn't a "difference of opinion".
    I completely agree that racism is not a difference of opinion. I bolded what I was questioning. In this case, friends were "lost" because they agreed with the jury's decision. Agreeing with the jury's decision to not indict does not a racist make.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I deleted 3 people from FB because they posted they "support traditional marriage". They probably aren't homophobic dickbags but I wasn't gonna wait around to find out. They weren't people I really hung out with in real life and only one of then ever asked about being unfriended.

    And I've blocked someone who posts a lot of prolife stuff. In real life we hang out and have fun together. But online? I just don't want to see it. Abortion rarely comes up in our real lives together.

    I'm mostly just reading along with this thread. Just wanted to give my own anecdotal Facebook stories.
  • SBminiSBmini member
    5 Love Its First Comment First Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited November 2014
    This is an excellent read about what can happen when you do associate with people who have extremely different opinions than you do. Meet Daryl Davis, the African American man who befriended several high up members in the KKK. After DECADES of friendship, three high ranking clansmen retired, and gave him their robes because they realized that they could not continue to believe what they believed because of Daryl. 20 people in total left the klan as a result of meeting him.

    He single handedly took down the KKK in Maryland not through anger or violence or anger and isolation, but through friendship: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2512411/When-enemies-talking-theyre-fighting-Meet-man-career-befriending-members-KKK.html

    I'm not saying all of us need to do this, but when I see people post about pro-life this or traditional marriage that, I tend to ignore it or just offer a thoughtful comment on the other side. Not to start an argument, but just to leave them with something to think about. In time, perhaps, they'll see things differently. But no one will have an opportunity to learn and grow if we only engage with people who share the same world views as our own.
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards